Rex reads this chapter. Tap a line to start there.

Introduction

Before We Open Either Book

I want to begin where I think every book written on this continent should begin, which is by saying whose ground the words are standing on.

I am Gilburri Fahy. I am a Kabi man, Kabi Kabi and Gubbi Gubbi, from the Sunshine Coast and hinterland side of south-east Queensland, and I carry the Mary Valley with me wherever I go. I'm writing this on Country that has never, in my understanding, been ceded by my people. That is my position and I hold it plainly: I do not accept that the Crown ever acquired the right to give away what was never the Crown's to give. You are free to disagree with that. I'd only ask that you notice how strange it feels to be asked to argue about it, as though the question of who owns a place were a matter of opinion for the newcomers and not a matter of fact for the people who were already here.

I should say, too, that I speak for myself. I am not the council of Kabi Kabi Elders, I am not the corporation that holds my people's native title, and I am not the voice of every Kabi Kabi or Gubbi Gubbi person. Nor do I speak for our Jinibara neighbours, whose connection to the same mountains is every bit as deep as ours and whose stories I will respect by not telling them for them. What I can do is read, and tell you honestly what I see when a Kabi man opens two of the most successful wildlife books ever written about the place where he comes from.

I'm also, as some of you will know, the writer of the Blackfella/Jewfella project, a story about living between worlds that don't always know what to do with a person who stands in two of them. I mention it because that project taught me something I carry into this one: you can only tell the truth about a thing when you are willing to be uncomfortable, and willing to let other people be uncomfortable, too. This book will make some people uncomfortable. I hope it will do it fairly.

The two books on the table

The first book is The Last Crocodile Hunter: A Father and Son Legacy, by Bob Irwin with Amanda French, published by Allen & Unwin in 2016. Bob is Steve Irwin's father. He and his late wife Lyn started the reptile park in Beerwah that, over the following decades, grew into Australia Zoo. The book is partly Bob's life story (a plumber from the foothills of the Dandenong Ranges in Victoria who becomes a zookeeper in Queensland), partly the story of his son, and partly a record of the conservation work he has done since Steve died. It's dedicated "For Lyn and Steve."

The second book is Steve & Me, by Terri Irwin, published by Simon Spotlight Entertainment in 2007. Terri is Steve's widow. She was an American from Oregon who came to Australia in 1991 to find a home for rescued cougars, walked into a reptile park in Beerwah, and met the man she would marry. It's a love story, a business story, a television story, and, after the final chapters, a story of grief. It is dedicated to Bindi and Robert, her children.

I went through the text of both books for this project, searching them and reading closely every passage that touches on land, wildlife and Aboriginal people, and I came to them as a person who loves reading and has no wish to sneer. These books are written by people who have lost someone dear to them. I will never forget that while I write, and nothing in the pages that follow is meant to treat their loss lightly. Steve Irwin died in 2006, and plenty of people who never met him mourned him as though they had. I understand why. He was, by the way both books tell it, a man of enormous energy whose love of animals often ran well ahead of his caution. Bob, in his book, is clearly a devoted father and husband, and Terri is a loving partner and a determined conservationist. I'm not going to pretend otherwise, and I'm not going to attack anybody's character.

What I am going to do is ask a different set of questions than the ones the books ask of themselves.

What is missing, exactly?

When I first started this project, the working idea in my head was a simple one: that these books say nothing about the Traditional Owners of the land where the Irwins built their business. It's a clean, angry sentence. It's also, as it turns out, not quite true, and I want to correct it at the start, because a critic who isn't careful with the facts is just another person with an opinion.

So I went through the text of both books and searched them for every sign of us. This is what I found.

In neither book do the words Kabi, Gubbi Gubbi, Jinibara, or Traditional Owner appear anywhere. Not once. Neither book uses the word Dreamtime. Neither tells the story of the mountain that gave the town its name.

But in The Last Crocodile Hunter, Aboriginal or Indigenous people are mentioned in five passages across a book of well over a hundred thousand words. Bob writes of sitting his young son Steve down and "making him learn how to survive in the bush, how to orienteer by himself—all of those things the Indigenous people of this land knew by instinct" (Ch. 2, p. 51). On a trip to Windorah, in central-west Queensland, Bob, Steve and Peter find "areas in the escarpment country where the Indigenous people had lived in ancient times—we found signs of where they'd made their tools and where they'd camped" (Ch. 2, p. 61). In the crocodile chapters, Bob writes that "Aboriginal people had long hunted crocodiles for their meat using traditional methods," but that the impact on crocodile numbers "had been minimal until the advent of .303 rifles in the 1940s" (Ch. 4, p. 99). The herpetologist John Cann, naming a new turtle, writes that "irwini" was "a departure from the Aboriginal names that I traditionally gave to describing new species" (Ch. 4, p. 133). And near the end of the book Bob describes fighting "to highlight the need for change to the Native Title Act which allows the slaughter of endangered dugongs and sea turtles," adding "Cruelty is cruelty; it isn't a matter of race" (Ch. 14, pp. 253–254).

That is the whole of it. Five passages.

In Steve & Me there are three. In the chapter called "Burdekin," Terri writes that Steve "talked about the area's Aborigines. He pointed out a butte where European colonists massacred a host of the Aboriginal population in Victorian times." In "Bindi Sue," she explains that her daughter's name "fit that the word 'bindi' was Aboriginal for 'young girl.'" And in "On the Road Again," the family visits Uluru, "The Aborigines knew it as Uluru, and they preferred that tourists did not clamber over their sacred site," and the crew "respectfully filmed only the areas we were allowed to access with the local Aborigines' blessing."

Notice the grammar. *Knew. Had lived. Had hunted. Preferred.* We turn up in these books mostly in the past tense, mostly in passing, mostly somewhere else, and almost never with a name, a language, or a living person attached. The Glass House Mountains, the great landmark of the Irwins' own address, are named exactly once in Bob's book, and that is to explain where a tree came from. In Terri's they appear exactly once as well, as the name of the motel where Steve put her up on the first night.

I'm going to come back to every one of those passages, because they deserve closer reading than a list can give them. I want to be fair to them. Some of them are kind. One of them, Steve's remark about the massacre, is more than I expected. But I also want to say, now, that I think the real story isn't absence; it's shape. The shape of a book that makes room for Indigenous people as history, as scenery, as the thing that "knew by instinct," and as a policy problem, but not as neighbours, not as owners, not as people with a claim on the very ground the story stands on.

A word about "terra nullius"

I'm going to use one Latin phrase in this book, and I'd like to explain it so nobody feels talked down to.

Terra nullius means "land belonging to no one." When Britain claimed the east coast of this continent in 1770 and settled it from 1788, it did so on the legal fiction that Australia was, in the eyes of the law, land belonging to no one. Not unowned because nobody was here; British law simply decided that we weren't the sort of people who could own land, so the land was available. That idea sat at the foundation of Australian property law for two hundred years. It was overturned in 1992, in the High Court's Mabo decision, which recognised that the Meriam people of the Murray Islands had held rights in their land before the Crown arrived and that those rights had not simply vanished.

Here's what I want you to understand. A legal fiction doesn't die the day a court rejects it. It lives on in habits, in language, in the way a story is told. Nobody today needs to believe, consciously, that Aboriginal people don't exist or don't matter. It's enough that the story begins with the arrival of the white person and that the land is described as for sale, untouched, remote, pristine, vacant, uninhabited, or wild. Those words do the work of the old doctrine without ever saying its name.

Let me show you what I mean, because the sentence I keep returning to comes from the opening of the Irwins' business story, in Bob's account of finding the place that would become the reptile park:

"In November 1972, on a field trip to catch snakes for snake contractors in south-east Queensland, we found the perfect three-and-a-half-acre property for sale beside the main highway in a town called Beerwah. So we bought it, and that was that." (Ch. 1, p. 35)

I'm not accusing Bob Irwin of breaking the law. By every sign in the book, he did the lawful thing: he found land for sale, and he bought it. My complaint is not that he did something illegal. My complaint is much bigger and much harder to answer, and it's about the law itself, and the way a good, hardworking, ordinary man can walk through the ruins of a dispossession and see only a bargain. So we bought it, and that was that. It was not that. It was never that. There was a mountain there, and a people, and a very long story. But the grammar of the sentence has no room for any of them.

I'll say this again, because I want it to be heard: this is an opinion about how a text works, not an accusation about a man's heart. I don't know Bob Irwin's heart. I know his book.

The bush, and the hunter

There are two other pieces of mythology in these books that I want to take seriously, because they're why people love them.

The first is the bush. Bob grew up at the foot of the Dandenong Ranges, in a little place called The Basin, and he says, "The bush became my school of life" (Ch. 1, p. 21). In her Author's note, Amanda French calls him "the last of his breed of bushman. He can tie any knot, track animals by instinct, survive in the bush and tell a bloody good yarn by the fire" (p. 13). Terri, in Steve & Me, tells Steve, "you are the most amazing bushman I've ever met" (Ch. 1), and later writes, "The best times in my life were out in the bush with Steve."

I understand the love in those lines. I love the bush too; I just have a different word for it, and the word is Country. The difference is not decoration. A bush is a place you go to. Country is a place that holds you. A bush is empty until someone fills it with a camping story. Country is full already, and always has been: full of obligations, of names, of other people's grandmothers. To call a place "bush" is to say, without saying it, that nobody lives here; that it is raw material for a personal story. When two books written by good people tell us that the bush was a "school," and that you can learn from it "by instinct," I want to ask: who taught the school before the new teachers arrived? And why are we the ones described as having had "instinct" instead of knowledge?

That last word matters. Instinct is what animals have. Knowledge is what people build, argue over, test, teach, and pass on. When Bob says that the Indigenous people of this land "knew by instinct" how to find their way, he is paying us a compliment, and I'm sure he means it as one. But it is a compliment that takes away our minds. Our ancestors did not navigate by instinct. They navigated by a body of law, story, song, and close study, a body of knowledge handed carefully from person to person over more than a thousand generations, as precise as any science, and a great deal older than the books Bob read when he taught himself about reptiles.

The second piece of mythology is the crocodile hunter. It's right there in the title of Bob's book and in the name the whole world gave his son. I'll deal with it properly in its own chapter, but I'll say now that one of the more interesting things about Bob's version is how much he insists that he and Steve were not hunters. He says he and Steve took a government contract "to save them by catching them as part of a government scheme to remove nuisance crocodiles" (as a landholder, Stephen Accornero, remembers Bob telling him in Ch. 4, p. 106). And in the chapter called "Goodbye to croc catching," he describes the end of that work. So even the book's own title sits a little awkwardly with its contents. It carries the legend of the hunter while telling the story of a man who says he came to fight the shooting of crocodiles.

Where does that leave a Kabi man? In a funny spot, honestly. I can't hate a man who spent his life trying to stop crocodiles being shot for handbags. I can, though, ask what it means that the world's most famous story about crocodiles and Australia is a story about two white men, and not about the people who've shared rivers and coasts with crocodiles for tens of thousands of years and who have their own names, laws, and stories for them. I can ask who got the television contract.

A fair warning about fairness

I've told you I want to be fair. Let me tell you what that means in practice, because I think it's the only way a book like this earns the right to be pointed.

First, it means that every quotation in this book is checked against the actual text, and I tell you where it comes from. If I say that Bob wrote something, you can go and look. For Bob's book I cite the chapter and the page of the electronic edition I read; for Terri's, which came as an ebook without fixed pages, I cite the chapter. If I get something wrong, I want to be told.

Second, it means I won't invent anything about the Irwin family, their private lives, their motives, or their characters. There's a particular kind of book that gets written about famous people, which finds a gap in the record and fills it with something nasty. It would be easy to write that book. I won't. I wouldn't want it done to my family, and in any case it would make the real argument weaker. If the real argument isn't strong enough to stand on what's actually in the books, it isn't strong enough.

Third, it means I'll say when I'm giving an opinion, and I'll say when I'm giving a fact, and I'll try never to let one dress up as the other. When I talk about Kabi Kabi history, I'll draw on public sources: the Queensland Government, the Federal Court, the Sunshine Coast Council, the national parks service, and I'll say so. Where I'm speaking from my own understanding as a Kabi man, I'll tell you that too.

And fourth, it means I'll give credit when it's due. These books describe real animals saved and real habitat protected. Bob and Terri have spent big parts of their lives on things I care about too. Ironbark Station, Mourachan, and the other properties they describe, tens of thousands of acres put aside for wildlife, are not nothing. When Amanda French describes Bob apologising to a nest of ants before digging them up, "putting things back the way he had found them" (Author's note, p. 13), I believe it, and I think it's one of the loveliest things in the whole book. That's exactly why I'm bothered: the man who knows how to apologise to the ants in their burrow tells the story of building his park in Beerwah without once, that I can find, acknowledging the people of the place where he built it.

I should be careful with that sentence. It is an opinion. It's possible that Bob, or Terri, or the zoo, has done things in private, or in later years, that the books don't record. If so, I'd be glad to hear it, and I'd put it in. A book can only be judged by what's in it.

What a Kabi reading adds

You might ask what a Kabi reading brings that a conservation journal or a literary reviewer wouldn't. I think it brings three things.

The first is place. Most reviews of the Irwin books treat Australia Zoo as if it were a brand that fell out of the sky onto a patch of nowhere. For me, it's an address. It's at the foot of a particular mountain, a mountain with a name older than the English language, in a region where my people held ceremony, traded, and feasted when the bunya was in season. The books almost never see that. I'm going to keep bringing the camera back to the ground.

The second is time. The Irwins' Beerwah story starts in the early 1970s. Ours doesn't. When I read that the family "opened the park on 11 April 1973," I also read, in the same sentence, the long centuries before 1973. A reptile park isn't a beginning. It is an episode in a story that's older than the pyramids and still going.

The third is relationship. I'm interested in how people relate to animals. Not as a hobby or a business or a brand, but as kin, as neighbours, with obligations running both ways. I'm not going to make cheap claims about how "Aboriginal people" feel about "animals," because there are hundreds of nations on this continent with hundreds of ways of understanding the living world, and I'm one man. But I can talk about how my own mob understands the relationship, and I can compare it, honestly, to the relationship the Irwin books describe. I think the contrast has something to teach, and I think it's more interesting than the cartoon version, in which one side loves animals and the other side doesn't.

A word about the title

Yes, the title is a bit cheeky. I'd rather say why than pretend it isn't.

The badminton part comes straight from the two books, and I'll stick to what they say. In The Last Crocodile Hunter, Bob tells us that in his Victorian years he was "playing professional badminton" in the evenings and that his "competitive approach had won me the title of Victorian state champion" (Prologue, p. 16). After the move to Queensland he wrote that "I decided that when I left Victoria I wouldn't go back to playing professional badminton" and that "after eleven solid years, I gave it up, just like that" (Ch. 2, pp. 37-38). He says Queensland selectors came and asked him to represent the state, and that he turned them down. In Steve & Me, Terri calls Bob "an expert badminton player" and tells the story of a young Steve marking out a badminton court in the backyard and a pet brolga named Brolly objecting to it (Ch. 12). That's the whole of it. A man who was good at a sport, left it for his family, and, by his own account, never thought about it again.

I like it as a symbol, and here's my opinion of why. It's a small, ordinary fact about a man the books otherwise describe as a bushman, a hunter, a collector and a legend, and it reminds me that the Irwins are people, not statues, and that the story of that piece of ground has been told mostly through their eyes. I'd like to read it with the same plain affection they bring to it, and still ask the questions I need to ask. The "Reptile" part is the park itself, which the books call the Beerwah Reptile Park and the Queensland Reptile and Fauna Park. The "Funpark" is mine, and it's a joke about how a place on Kabi Country has turned into a brand. Nothing in the title is meant to say anything about anyone's private life, and nothing in this book does.

The subtitle stays because it still says what the book is: a Kabi man, reading.

How this book is built

The book moves in twelve chapters, and an afterword.

It begins at the mountain, in the first chapter, with what Beerwah is, and what the Irwins' books make of it. Then it follows the Irwins' own story, through Bob's boyhood and the idea of "the bush," through the early collecting years and the Fauna Conservation Act, and into a close reading of the eight passages where we do appear. After that, it takes on the two great legends, "the crocodile hunter" and "untouched wilderness"; it looks at the question of permission, and at the question of money; it turns to the Irwins' land-buying conservation, to the Native Title and dugong passage, and to the use of Aboriginal words and places in Terri's book. The last chapter is different. It is not about what's wrong. It's about what could be different, and what it might look like if the biggest wildlife attraction in the country, sitting on Kabi Kabi and Jinibara Country, were to share more than its address.

Along the way, I'll keep asking the same few questions: *Whose Country is this? Who was here? Who is asked, and who is just informed? Who profits? And whose story gets told as the story of the place?*

I don't expect the Irwin family to agree with everything I say. I'm not sure I'd want them to; it would suggest I hadn't said anything. But I'd like them to read it, as I read theirs. I'd like their readers to read it. And I'd like my own people to read it and to know that somebody from our side of the ground sat down with the books everybody else has been reading and, politely and firmly, answered back.

That, in the end, is all this book is: an answer from the ground.

Let's go to the mountain.


Notes

Source key. LCH = Bob Irwin & Amanda French, The Last Crocodile Hunter (Allen & Unwin, 2016); page numbers are pages of the supplied PDF (no printed page numbers in the e-edition). S&M = Terri Irwin, Steve & Me (Simon Spotlight, 2007); ebook, cited by chapter.

Quotations verified against extracted text (`sources/pdf.txt`, `sources/mobi.txt`):

  • LCH Ch 1 p. 35: "In November 1972, on a field trip to catch snakes for snake contractors in south-east Queensland, we found the perfect three-and-a-half-acre property for sale beside the main highway in a town called Beerwah. So we bought it, and that was that." ✔
  • LCH Ch 2 p. 51: "all of those things the Indigenous people of this land knew by instinct" ✔
  • LCH Ch 2 p. 61: "areas in the escarpment country where the Indigenous people had lived in ancient times—we found signs of where they'd made their tools and where they'd camped." (Place: Windorah, central-west Qld, from the preceding page.) ✔
  • LCH Ch 4 p. 99: "While Aboriginal people had long hunted crocodiles for their meat using traditional methods, the impact of hunting on crocodile populations had been minimal until the advent of .303 rifles in the 1940s" ✔
  • LCH Ch 4 p. 133 (speaker is Dr John Cann, quoted/paraphrased within Bob's chapter): "a departure from the Aboriginal names that I traditionally gave to describing new species" ✔
  • LCH Ch 14 pp. 253–254: "to highlight the need for change to the Native Title Act which allows the slaughter of endangered dugongs and sea turtles… Cruelty is cruelty; it isn't a matter of race." ✔
  • LCH Ch 1 p. 21: "The bush became my school of life." ✔ (Bob on The Basin / Dandenong foothills, Ch 1 pp. 20–22.)
  • LCH Author's note (Amanda French) p. 13: "Bob is the last of his breed of bushman. He can tie any knot, track animals by instinct, survive in the bush and tell a bloody good yarn by the fire."; apologising to ants / "putting things back the way he had found them" ✔
  • LCH Ch 4 p. 106: Stephen Accornero's account — Bob says they want "not to hunt crocodiles but to save them by catching them as part of a government scheme to remove nuisance crocodiles from our creek" (this is Accornero's recollection of what Bob said, as printed in the book). ✔
  • LCH Ch 4 p. 135: the Glasshouse Mountains named once (felled stringybark / railway). ✔ S&M Ch 1: "Glasshouse Mountains Motel". ✔
  • S&M Ch 4 "Burdekin": "Steve talked about the area's Aborigines. He pointed out a butte where European colonists massacred a host of the Aboriginal population in Victorian times." ✔
  • S&M Ch 11 "Bindi Sue": "it also fit that the word 'bindi' was Aboriginal for 'young girl.'" ✔
  • S&M Ch 13 "On the Road Again": Uluru / "with the local Aborigines' blessing" ✔
  • S&M Ch 7 "Stacks of Fun": "The best times in my life were out in the bush with Steve." ✔ (Chapter assignment by position in the text.)
  • S&M Ch 1: Terri to Steve: "Steve, you are the most amazing bushman I've ever met" (extracted text line 151, within Chapter One). ✔

Consistency: "eight passages" = 5 (LCH) + 3 (S&M).

Search method. Full-text search of both extracted books for: Aborigin*, Indigenous, Traditional Owner, Kabi, Gubbi, Jinibara, Dreamtime, Koori, Native Title, elder, Glass House/Glasshouse, Tibrogargan, Coonowrin. Word counts approximate: LCH ≈ 117,000 words (extraction incl. front/back matter); S&M ≈ 75,000.

External facts used.

  • Mabo v Queensland (No 2) (1992) 175 CLR 1, High Court of Australia, 3 June 1992 — rejected terra nullius, recognised native title of the Meriam people (Mer / Murray Islands). Well established; no fresh lookup done.
  • Steve Irwin died 4 September 2006 (Batt Reef; S&M Ch 18). Well established.
  • Beerwah / Glass House Mountains significance to Jinibara and Kabi Kabi peoples: Queensland Parks & Wildlife Service, "Legend of the Glasshouse Mountains" page; DCCEEW, "Glass House Mountains National Landscape" (names Gubbi Gubbi and Jinibara). https://visitsunshinecoasthinterland.com.au/the-legend-of-the-glasshouse-mountains/ ; https://www.dcceew.gov.au/parks-heritage/heritage/places/national/glass-house-mountains
  • British claim 1770 / settlement 1788: standard history.

Author to confirm. (1) "Mary Valley" as home — appears in his own saved chat; confirm he wants it printed. (2) The self-description "Kabi Kabi and Gubbi Gubbi" is as given by the author. (3) "not ceded" is stated as his position; the Federal Court has made a native title determination (17 June 2024) — see Chapter 1 notes — so ensure the framing in his own words is comfortable with that.

  • Title section (author's OK needed): facts are from LCH Prologue p. 16 (state champion, "professional badminton"), Ch. 2 pp. 37-38 ("eleven solid years", Queensland selectors turned down), and S&M Ch. 11 ("expert badminton player", Brolly the brolga). The sentences about what the title means to me, and the "Funpark" joke, are written in your voice by me as a guess: please confirm or rewrite.