An open letter to readers of the Irwin books
Dear reader,
If you've come this far, you've read a long argument about two books that you may love. Maybe you grew up on Steve's television shows. Maybe you cried at the funeral, along with, as The Last Crocodile Hunter has it, "over 300 million people" who "tuned in to join us in remembering our leader, our hero" (LCH, Ch. 11, p. 224, in Judy Irwin's chapter). Maybe you've been to the Zoo with your kids. Maybe you've never heard of any of it until now.
Whichever you are, I'd like to say some things plainly.
I'm not against the Irwins. I've said it throughout, and I'll say it again at the end, because the point can get lost. Bob Irwin, in his own book, writes about a life spent with animals and land, and about a son he lost. Terri Irwin writes about a husband she loved. Their books are about grief, family, work and a deep feeling for living things. I've quoted them at length because there's a lot in them I admire. They bought back bush. They fought for animals. They've said, in print, things I agree with, and I tried to say so each time.
I'm not saying they knew. I can't. I don't know what anyone in that family knew or thought about the Aboriginal history under their feet, and I've tried never to claim to. What I can say is what's on the page, and what isn't. Neither book names the Kabi Kabi or the Jinibara people. Neither explains the word Beerwah. Neither tells the story of the mountains. In a few places, a sentence about Aboriginal people appears, kindly meant, and then the book moves on.
I'm saying the absence matters. Not because anyone is guilty, but because the absence of a people from the story of their own place is what colonisation looks like when it has become quiet. Nobody has to do anything hostile. All it takes is for the story to be told without us, over and over, until it feels complete.
I'm saying it can be fixed. That's the part I most want you to take away. You don't need a demolition. You need a paragraph, a sign, a footnote, an agreement signed, a job offered, a seat at the table, and a cup of tea. Chapter 12 has a list. The Irwin family are, as I've said, good at generosity. They could do this beautifully, and if they did, I think they'd be the better for it, and so would the rest of us.
What I'd ask of you
If you're a reader, a visitor, or a fan, here's what I'd ask.
Learn whose Country you're on. Wherever you are, there is a people, and a name, and a language. Look it up. If you're on the Sunshine Coast, you're on the Country of the Kabi Kabi and the Jinibara peoples, and the Council's own heritage pages say so. If you're somewhere else, find out. It takes a minute and it changes how you see the place.
Notice the word "untouched." Next time you read it or hear it about a landscape, ask: by whom? A lot of what looks like wilderness is garden, and it's a garden because someone has been looking after it.
Ask the next question. When a story says "the land was bought" or "the area was discovered" or "the bush was empty," ask what came before. It's not rude. It's what a curious person does.
Listen to the people who are here. Not to me, particularly. I'm one man with a laptop and some opinions. Listen to the Traditional Owners, the rangers, the language workers, the Elders and the young people. Go to their events. Read what they write. Pay them for their work. The cheapest and most powerful thing you can do is sit down and listen.
Don't let it make you despair. It's very easy to read all this and feel that the country is built on something terrible, and then feel helpless. I don't want that. I want you to feel what I feel when I stand under Beerwah: a mixture of grief and gladness. The mountain is still there. We are still here. There is a lot of work to do, and it's work you can start today.
And to the Irwin family
If the family were ever to read this, I'd want to say a few things directly, as one person to another.
I'm sorry if any of it has hurt. It's not meant to. I've tried to quote you fairly, I've tried to give you the credit where it's due, and I've tried to say where I might be wrong. If I've got something wrong, I'd like to be told, and I'll correct it.
I think Bob is right that cruelty is cruelty. I think he's wrong that it isn't a matter of race, but I think he's wrong in a way that can be put right with a conversation, and I'd welcome the conversation.
And I'd like to say, as I said at the beginning, that Beerwah is a wonderful place. You've lived at the foot of it for decades. You know, better than I do, the feeling of looking up and seeing it there. It's the same feeling my people have had for as long as there have been people here. We have more in common than this book makes it sound.
So: come to the mountain. Come and sit down. I'll bring the tea.
gilburri fahy Kabi man