I've spent eleven chapters saying what the Irwin books leave out. This one is for saying what I'd like to see put in.
I want to begin with a scene from the very last pages of The Last Crocodile Hunter, because it's the best argument I know for what I'm about to propose, and it was written by someone who isn't me.
A cup of tea at Koolatah
The Epilogue is by Amanda French, Bob's co-author, and it's set at Koolatah Station, on Cape York, in September 2015. She and Bob have spent three weeks camping on the property. Before they leave they stop at the homestead "to have a cup of tea with the property's managers, Alby and Andrew." And she writes: "We always like to share with Alby and Andrew some of the adventures we've had camping on their property. We tell them about the black-throated finches we've seen, and other rare birds, and the snakes that have slithered across our path. Their focus is primarily on running cattle so they rarely venture to some of the areas we've explored, and they're only too happy to learn more about their land, the way we've been looking at it with the wildlife in our eyes." (LCH, Epilogue, p. 267.)
I think that's a lovely paragraph. Two groups of people who know different things about the same piece of land sit down together and swap what they know. The visitors bring their eyes for wildlife; the managers bring their knowledge of the station; everybody goes away knowing more. No one is lecturing. Nobody is giving anything up. It costs a cup of tea.
A few lines later Amanda writes about how Bob treats the people who come up to him to talk about Steve: "He always enthusiastically listens" (p. 268). I believe that. I think Bob is a man who, in the right circumstances, is a very good listener.
So that is my whole proposal, really. It's the Koolatah cup of tea, at Beerwah. It's two sets of people, who know different things about the same Country, sitting down together. One of them has the zoo, the books and the world's attention. The other has sixty-five thousand years, give or take, of knowing the mountains (that figure is the Madjedbebe estimate I cited in Chapter 9, and it's from a different part of the continent; I'm using it only as a reminder of scale). I don't think either of them has everything. I think they'd each be better for the tea.
What follows are ideas. I've tried to keep them small, specific and practical. I'm one Kabi man; I can't speak for the Kabi Kabi people or the Jinibara people, and nothing in this chapter is a demand on anyone's behalf. If any of it is ever taken up, the Traditional Owners will decide what they want, how, and with whom. They may want none of it. They may want something much better. What I'm offering is a way to start the conversation, not a plan to impose.
First, what's already been done
Fairness first. The Zoo and the family have done things in this direction, and I should say what I know.
In Chapter 9 I reported that a document attributed to Australia Zoo, lodged with a parliamentary inquiry, says that since the Steve Irwin Wildlife Reserve was declared the zoo "has been working towards developing an 'Indigenous Land Use Agreement' with the Traditional Owners," and lists ranger-training work and the employment of a Traditional Owner as a ranger on the reserve. (I could read only an excerpt, and I've flagged it for checking.) In the same chapter I reported the reserve's ranger, in 2013, saying that "we have traditional owners actively involved in fire management, wildlife research, cultural site surveys and management," and that he was "keen to see an ILUA finalised."
Those are good things, and if they're accurate, then the family and its staff have already begun to do what I'm going to suggest. The people who told the ABC that they'd been denied access said something else, and I reported that too, and I don't know the situation today. My point is that the door isn't shut. There are people on the Zoo's side of the table who've said, in public, that they want an agreement.
What I want to see is what happens when the same habit is applied to the place where the family lives.
The book first
The cheapest thing to change is the book. The Last Crocodile Hunter and Steve & Me are still in print, and books can be revised. I'd propose seven small revisions. None would need a word removed; they're all additions.
- An acknowledgement at the front. A paragraph, in the Traditional Owners' words if they'd like to write it, saying that the story took place on Kabi Kabi and Jinibara Country, and that the families who've been here for tens of thousands of years are still here. The books already have dedications and acknowledgements to many people; this would be one more.
- *The meaning of Beerwah.* As I asked in Chapter 11: one sentence, written with the custodians.
- A note on "untouched." In Chapter 7, I discussed the places the books call "untouched" or "pristine." A footnote could say: Many of these places are Aboriginal Country, cared for for a very long time. Not a retraction. A footnote.
- A paragraph on Lakefield / Rinyirru. In Chapter 6 I wrote a hypothetical paragraph in square brackets. The real one, written by the people of that Country, would be better.
- A line about the Mary River. The book mentions the Mary Valley campaign; it might add that Kabi Kabi and Gubbi Gubbi people were part of it, and that the river has a name in their language.
- A new page for "Cruelty is cruelty." If the family still wants to make the argument that animal-welfare law should apply to everyone equally, it should be accompanied by the case that Aboriginal people make for customary rights recognised in law. The two can sit side by side. Readers are adults.
- An invitation. A page at the back that says: If you are a Traditional Owner and you'd like to tell your own part of this story, here is how to reach us.
None of that is a punishment for anyone. It's an editorial decision, and the cost is a few pages.
The place second
The Zoo is a very large visitor attraction. By its own books, it started as a roadside reptile park, and a crocodile carved from a felled tree stood at the gate (LCH Ch. 4, p. 135). I won't list what's there now, because I haven't been through it for this book and I'm not going to describe what I haven't seen. So take these as ideas, and take them to be "if possible, and if wanted."
Welcome to Country at the gate. A recognised custodian, speaking for the Country, in person or on a sign. The best welcomes aren't a formality; they're a lesson in the first five minutes about where you are.
The mountains, told by their custodians. At Beerwah, the story of the Glass House Mountains is a big story: there's the Council's one-line version I quoted in Chapter 11 and there's a much bigger one that belongs to the Kabi Kabi and Jinibara people. It's not mine to tell and it's not the Zoo's. But the Zoo has millions of visitors, and a place at its gate for the Traditional Owners to tell it, in their own voices, would reach more people than any museum.
The animals, in the language of the place. The idea I raised in Chapter 11: names of animals on signs in the local language, if the custodians would like it and have helped.
Aboriginal-led tours and talks. Not a performance in a costume. A walk with an Aboriginal guide who knows the plants and animals and can say what each is for. People pay a lot to be taken to the bush by someone who knows it. Those people could be Kabi Kabi and Jinibara people, employed and paid properly.
A cultural-knowledge fund. If the Zoo and the books draw on Aboriginal knowledge, in names, in stories and in the presence of the mountains, a share of the proceeds could be directed to a Kabi Kabi and Jinibara language and culture program. That's not charity. It's what a fair exchange looks like.
The people third
An institution is its people. The most useful thing that a big employer in a district can do for the Traditional Owners of that district is hire them, train them, and keep them.
I'd put it plainly. Jobs, traineeships, and a clear path to leadership. Not only for ranger work or for guiding but for the bits of a zoo that don't get on television: vets, keepers, educators, managers, accountants, grounds crews. A zoo is a large business, and a large business needs a lot of kinds of people.
Scholarships for Aboriginal students in veterinary science, zoology, or wildlife management, in the family's name.
An Aboriginal advisory group with real authority. I've seen the word "advisory" misused. I mean a group whose advice is listened to, and which is paid for its time. The Zoo might also ask who the right people are before it asks the group to form; the Traditional Owners will know.
The Country fourth
Here the Irwin family have a very large footprint. Their books describe property in several places: Ironbark near Blackbutt, Mourachan, the Cape York reserve, the Tasmanian land (Chapter 9). Whatever the legal position, every one of those places is somebody's Country.
I'd ask for three things.
Finish the agreement at Cape York. The Zoo has said, in the document I quoted, that it has been working towards an Indigenous Land Use Agreement. An agreement that's finished, signed and published would mean more than any statement. I don't know how close it is, and I don't know where the delay lies. The ranger said in 2013 that part of the matter rested with the Cape York Land Council, and the Traditional Owners had their own view. I don't want to take sides. I'd only say: whatever the obstacles, finishing it would be the best story the reserve could have.
Join the crocodile work to the Traditional Owners. In Chapters 5 and 6, I looked at the crocodile research at Lakefield. Rinyirru is now, as I described in Chapter 6, part of a joint-management arrangement. The same research team could work with the rangers, train them, and share the data and the credit. The Zoo has said it did crocodile-capture training with Kaanju rangers. That's the right kind of thing. I'd like to see more of it, and I'd like to see it in the book.
Put the Mary River in the plan. In Chapter 4 I reported on the Traditional Owner survey of the Mary River in 2023 and 2024. Kabi Kabi and Gubbi Gubbi people are doing work on the river's turtles and fish with scientists. There are surely ways for Wildlife Warriors to support them, if it hasn't already.
The law fifth
I'll be brief, because I covered this in Chapter 10.
If the Irwin family wants to hold to "Cruelty is cruelty; it isn't a matter of race," then I'd ask them to look at what's already been proposed by people who care about animals and about Aboriginal rights: traditional use agreements, in which Aboriginal groups work with government on how a species is cared for; paid Indigenous rangers; and a conversation with the people actually affected. Several senators, from several parties, said as much in 2017 (Chapter 10). I'd suggest that the Irwin voice, which carries a long way, could say so too.
I don't expect Bob to change his mind because of a book. I would hope he'd say it again with these things in the sentence. That's all.
What it would cost, and what it would buy
I want to be honest about this part, because it's easy to write a list of good ideas and pretend they're free.
They're not free. Some of them cost money, a lot of them cost time, and some cost a bit of pride. They'd mean sharing the stage. They'd mean the family handing over some of the telling of its own story. They'd mean, in places, hearing "no."
And I understand that the family have been through a very great deal. Steve died in 2006, and the books are, in large part, about grief. Nothing in this chapter is a demand on a grieving family. It's an invitation to an institution, and an institution can say yes in its own time.
But I'd say what it would buy. It would buy a Zoo, and a family name, that was known not only as a place that saved animals but as a place that shared. It would buy a lot of goodwill in a district where goodwill matters. And it would buy something I think the Irwins, in their books, want. Bob says, in the Epilogue, that "Far North Queensland is where I feel most connected to Steve" (p. 268). That sense of connection to a place is exactly what Aboriginal people feel for their Country. It's the same thing. Two people, from very different backgrounds, standing in the same landscape and feeling it in their chests. That's a place to begin.
The invitation in the books
There's one last thing I want to put down.
At the back of Steve & Me, there's a page headed "Come Join Us." It reads: "Come join us in the effort to save the world's wildlife." It gives the address of Wildlife Warriors Worldwide.
I'd like to accept that invitation, on behalf of anyone who wants to. Aboriginal people have been doing wildlife work for a very long time, and I'd suggest that some of the best "wildlife warriors" in the country are the people who've been looking after the same river for tens of thousands of years and aren't on television. If the Irwin family means "come join us," I'd say: come and join us, too. Sit with us. Listen. And we'll tell you what we know.
That's it. That's what I'd want. Not a victory, not an apology, though one wouldn't hurt. Just a cup of tea, and the lid off the pot.
In the Afterword I'll say it to you directly.