Rex reads this chapter. Tap a line to start there.

Chapter 2

"The Bush Became My School of Life": Bob's Boyhood and the Bushman Myth

I want to begin this chapter by telling you what I like about Bob Irwin's childhood, because I do like it, and because if I don't say so now you'll think everything that follows is made of spite.

When Bob was a small boy in a tiny township at the foot of the Dandenong Ranges in Victoria, he was the "smallest kid in the district," he was bullied, and he found school a prison. "The Basin Primary School consisted of one room and felt just like a prison to me," he writes, and "trapped at my desk, I couldn't wait for the hours to pass so I could race home and get back down to the creek to see what creatures I could discover" (The Last Crocodile Hunter, Ch. 1, p. 21). He had a mother who told him, every time he came home with a frog or an eel or a little lizard, to take it "right back where you came from and let that go again" (p. 21). He stood in a patch of blackberries, accidentally "parked myself in the middle of a raging bull ants' nest," got bitten by the hundreds, and went back the next day, barefoot, "to curiously observe those ants move about their bustling city for hours" (p. 22).

Now, I've sat by a creek for hours watching things. So have you, or you ought to have. That boy with his boots cut open by his dad's leather knife is a recognisable person to me. He is a boy who has found the one place where the world makes sense, and who goes back to it every chance he gets.

"The bush became my school of life," he says (Ch. 1, p. 21). And a page later: "I gloried in the bush for years and years" (p. 22).

I believe him. I'd like to treat that belief as the starting point, not as something to be argued down. A man who knows a place as intimately as Bob knew that creek, who followed "every critter to see where it lived: in the hollows, in the mud, below the surface of the water" (p. 21), is a man with something real to offer. He knew, from childhood, how to watch.

So my question isn't whether Bob's love of the bush was genuine. It's a different one. It's the question this whole book is built around, and in this chapter I'm going to ask it of his boyhood in particular:

When a boy says the bush was his school, whose school was it before it was his?

A school with no teachers

Look at the way Bob describes how he learned. "The more I observed things out in the bush, the more insatiable my appetite grew to know more" (p. 21). He sits alone. He's "engrossed in my own untroubled world," "at ease in my own company," and he finds that "humans were a peculiar breed." Animals, by contrast, are honest: "If you mucked up, they bit you. But if you respected their space, they'd respect you too. It was as simple as that in the animal world and a lot more complicated when it came to humans" (p. 21).

I want to make two observations about that, and I'll try to make them gently.

The first is that it's a solitary education. There are teachers in this boyhood, and Bob names them with a lot of love: his mother with her coathangers and her blackberry pie, his dad Les (his stepfather, whom he says was "always Dad to me"), "a sturdy, incredibly tall man who was nevertheless remarkably tender, a true gentle giant," who "always had the time to stop and show me how to do things properly" (p. 20). Those teachers taught him how to work. They taught him to dig a hole fast and to fix a tank. But for the bush itself (the knowledge of the creek, the creatures, what lived in the hollows) there is no teacher in the story. The bush taught him, and he alone was the pupil.

The second is that this is how most settler Australians have been taught to think of knowledge about the land. The country is a book that a clever and patient person can read for himself, without reference to anyone who has read it before. You just go out and look. The land is there, it's honest, it's "as simple as that." And it comes with no previous readers.

I want to say as plainly as I can that this is not how any Aboriginal person I know learned the country. We were taught. We were taken to places by our old people and told what was there, what the place was called, what had happened there, who it belonged to, and what we had to do and not do. That teaching was a relationship. It took years, and it was rooted in obligations to people. It wasn't a matter of one clever child with a magnifying glass.

There's no malice in Bob's version. He was a poor kid in a small town who didn't have anyone to teach him this stuff and who taught himself. I'm moved by that. But when an entire culture takes that model, the solitary white boy in the empty bush, and makes it the model of how a person knows the land, something gets erased. What gets erased is the fact that the bush already had a school. It had had one for about sixty-five thousand years.

Whose "paddock"?

Bob describes the place where he played: "Our house was adjacent to a vast open paddock, filled with blackberry bushes and butting up against miles and miles of dense bush that sloped down to a flowing creek. . . . It was an idyllic place for a curious boy to grow up. It became my habitat, where I felt a sense of belonging" (p. 21).

A sense of belonging. I want to leave that sentence on the table for a moment.

I don't have any quarrel with it. To belong somewhere is the most basic human need, and a boy who finds it in the bush has found a good thing. But I'd ask you to look at what's in the sentence. A "vast open paddock" is a place somebody cleared. "Blackberry bushes" are a weed from Europe, spread by farmers and gardeners and now one of the more stubborn things in the Australian bush. The "miles and miles of dense bush" is what remains, and "a flowing creek" runs through it. Every one of those features has a history, and none of them is neutral. A paddock has a clearing. A blackberry has a gardener who came from somewhere. A creek has a name.

Here is what I can say about the country. The Basin, where Bob grew up, is in the foothills of the Dandenong Ranges, which are the Country of the Wurundjeri Woi-wurrung people of the Kulin Nation, with the Bunurong (Boon Wurrung) people to the south and east; the two Countries meet in the ranges. Local histories say that the Bunurong and other neighbouring groups also came to the Basin to hunt in the summer months. I should be clear that I am not a Kulin man and I am not the right person to tell the story of that Country. I'm telling you only that it has custodians, that they are named in public records, and that they appear nowhere in Bob's account of his boyhood.

And they weren't a thing of the distant past, either, even then. A report prepared in 2019 for the Yarra Ranges Council, together with the Wurundjeri and Bunurong corporations, lists among its themes the "tourist trade of the mid-20th century attracting Aboriginal entrepreneurs such as Bill Onus." That is the very era in which a boy in The Basin was running down to the creek. Bob's book doesn't give his birth year, but he tells us he married at nineteen when Lyn was eighteen, and that Steve was born on Lyn's twentieth birthday in 1962 (p. 25), which puts his own boyhood somewhere in the 1940s and 1950s. Aboriginal people were not only the subject of old stories in the Dandenongs when Bob was a boy. They were, according to that report, making a living in the tourist trade of those ranges, in the very ranges where he watched his ants.

I do not say that Bob should have known them. I don't know whether he did or didn't, and the book doesn't say. A child of that time and place was, I'd guess, unlikely to have been told much about it by the adults around him. My point is about what the book does with the memory. When Bob looks back, decades later, at the place where his love of the bush began, the people whose Country it was don't come back with it.

The man who "can track animals by instinct"

Which brings me to Amanda French's Author's note, which is the closest thing in the book to a statement of what it believes about Bob.

French spent time with him on the road while writing, and the portrait she draws is affectionate and, as far as I can tell, honest. She watches him apologise to a colony of ants. "When we set out one afternoon to dig up some ant burrows, he apologised to the inhabitants for digging up their home. When he had identified the ants, he replaced it all to the best of his ability, putting things back the way he had found them" (Author's note, p. 13). She writes, "I have also never met someone with more compassion than him, even for the tiniest little lizard." And then: "Bob is the last of his breed of bushman. He can tie any knot, track animals by instinct, survive in the bush and tell a bloody good yarn by the fire" (p. 13).

I want to give that apology to the ants its due. It's lovely. An elderly man saying sorry to insects before he digs up their burrow is a man who understands something I'd like more people to understand: that you owe something to the place you are taking from. That is, in a small way, exactly what we mean when we talk about Country and obligation. I don't think it's an accident that the person who recorded that detail chose it as her proof of his character.

But I have two questions about the sentence that follows.

First: the last of his breed. What breed? "Bushman," in this sense, isn't a description of anyone who lives in the bush. It's a type, a figure from the stories this country tells itself, the self-reliant white man who can read the landscape, walk out of any trouble, and tell a yarn at night. That figure has a long history in our books and films and ballads. And one thing the figure has always had in common is that he stands where an Aboriginal person once stood, doing what an Aboriginal person was once doing, and he stands there alone. When a settler is called "the last of his breed of bushman," the quiet suggestion is that the real thing, the true inheritor of the land's knowledge, is the white man with the Landcruiser and the billy tea.

Second: track animals by instinct. Of all the words in that passage, "instinct" is the one I most want to push on, because it recurs. Skills that are learned, over years, from other people, are very often described in this country as instinctive when they are practised by an Aboriginal person, and as expertise, or even genius, when they are practised by a white one. French uses the word of Bob. And Bob, a few chapters later, will use it of us.

"…the Indigenous people of this land knew by instinct"

The sentence is on page 51. Bob is describing the trips he took with his small son. Steve had just come down from a tree with a goanna's teeth in his hand and not complained. "Some of those trips with him were a nightmare," Bob writes, "because I'd only have to stop the truck somewhere and he'd be gone, disappearing outta sight. And so I made a point of sitting him down and making him learn how to survive in the bush, how to orienteer by himself—all of those things the Indigenous people of this land knew by instinct. These were vital life skills to have in the bush" (The Last Crocodile Hunter, Ch. 2, p. 51).

I'm going to read this slowly, because there's a lot in it.

First, it's a compliment. Bob is paying respect. He's saying that the skills of surviving and navigating in the bush are "vital," and that the people of this land had them. It's a bigger acknowledgement than many books of that era would give, and it comes unprompted. I give him credit for it.

Second, it is the only time in the first fifty pages that the original people of the land appear, and they appear in the past tense and in a subordinate clause. "Knew." Not "know." They are an example of what Steve needs to become, not a people who are still around and could, if anybody thought to ask, tell him how to find his way.

Third, it says "by instinct." Not by learning. Not by long teaching, by being taken out as a child and shown, by being told the stories that remember where the water is and how the country lies, by a system of knowledge, passed down, that is as complex and as tested as any science. Instinct. As if we came out of our mothers knowing it.

I have a view on what that word does, and I'll try to put it as an opinion and not a charge. I think "instinct" turns knowledge into nature. If you know the bush because you were taught, then you're a student and a culture-bearer, and someone owes you respect and probably a seat at the table. If you know the bush because it's in your blood, then you're a part of the landscape, like a wallaby, and the question of who owns the land, or whose law governs it, never has to arise.

And look what the sentence then asks Bob's own son to do. He has to be taught. He's made to sit down and learn: he's given instructions ("follow that body of water downstream and you'll always come out somewhere accessible"). His education is a matter of deliberate fathering. Ours, apparently, was a matter of birth. I don't think Bob intended that contrast. But there it is.

The ducks

I want to turn to Steve & Me for a moment, because Terri's book has a small story in its first chapter that I find sweeter, and wiser, than almost anything else in either book on the subject of the bushman.

It's October 1991. Terri and Steve have just had dinner at a resort in Caloundra. She has been loading her plate with prawns. A piece of crab flicks onto her arm and she eats it off her elbow, and Steve tells her, "Gosh, you aren't ladylike at all," which she takes as the best compliment of her life. They leave the restaurant. "As we left the restaurant, Steve said, 'You know, I smell ducks.' We walked outside, and sure enough, there was a flock of beautiful ducks bobbing around on a pond." And Terri says to him, "Steve, you are the most amazing bushman I've ever met."

Then she tells us the truth, and tells it on herself. "Of course, the resort and the pond had been there for years, and Steve had known about the ducks for just as long. 'I smell ducks' was a Crocodile Dundee trick that had nevertheless worked its magic on this naive American girl" (Steve & Me, Ch. 1).

I love this. It's honest, it's funny, and it contains a perfect picture of a performance. Steve, who was then a man of twenty-nine, was doing what a bushman does. He was putting on the character. And Terri, writing years later, sees through it, and says so, and doesn't mind.

So here is a thing I'd like to say about the figure of the bushman. It's a role. It's played well and with real skill by people who do know a lot about animals, and I'd say Bob and Steve both did. But the role is a performance of knowing the land, and part of the performance is that the land has no other knowers. When a man in a khaki shirt says, in effect, "I smell ducks," and the audience gasps, nobody asks whether the person next to him has known the pond for twenty thousand years.

Terri herself isn't naive about this. A few chapters on, she describes how Steve would sometimes wonder "if I'd married him just because I loved him, or if it was because he was a bit of Tarzan and Croc Dundee and Indiana Jones all rolled into one" (Steve & Me, Ch. 8). Those names are all fictional, and all three of them are white men who show up in somebody else's country and are better at it than the locals. Terri's book is, in this small way, aware of the genre it is living in. What it doesn't do is ask what the genre costs.

"The best times in my life"

In Chapter 7 Terri describes filming in the desert with Steve. "In the middle of this vast landscape were the two of us, the only people for miles. Steve had become adept at eluding the film crew from time to time so we could be alone." They make a campfire, watch a sunset, cook curry in a camp oven. They go spotlighting. And she writes: "The best times in my life were out in the bush with Steve" (Steve & Me, Ch. 7).

I'm happy for her. It's one of the most affecting lines in the book. She's a young woman in love, in a beautiful place, with a man who made the world look new to her.

And I'd like to read the paragraph again, at the point where she says "the only people for miles." Two paragraphs earlier she has told us about "a local cattle station about an hour-and-a-half drive from where we were filming, a small homestead in the middle of nowhere," whose owners invited the crew to a home-cooked meal. So the country is not empty. There are people at the station. There is a film crew. There are Bob and Lyn at their camp. "The only people for miles" is true as a lover's phrase, meaning "the only two people that mattered." What it can't mean is what the words say, that nobody else was around. And I can't say what Aboriginal people were living near that station, or visiting it, or working on it, because I don't know where it was, and she doesn't say. But I know one thing: in the middle of Australia, a country with a population that has been continuously present for tens of thousands of years, the phrase "in the middle of nowhere" is not a geographic statement. It's a statement about who counts.

I'm not saying Terri is lying, or hiding anything. I'm saying that this is the way our language works, and that she, like Bob, absorbed it as a child absorbs an accent. It sounds natural. It sounds like love. And it silently deletes a people.

A fair accounting

So what can I fairly say about Bob's boyhood and the bushman myth?

I can say that Bob's relationship with the bush is real and, in my opinion, to be admired in some respects. A man who spends his life learning to watch animals, and who begs their pardon before digging up their home, is doing something that matters.

I can say that the picture of that relationship, the one both books give us, is of a solitary white person learning from an empty landscape, and that I think it's a false and damaging picture. It is false because the landscape was never empty, and damaging because it helps generation after generation of Australians to believe that to love the bush is the same thing as to know it, and to know it is the same thing as to own it.

I can say that the single time Bob does mention the original people of the land, in that sentence about "instinct," he does so with respect, and he does so in the past tense.

And I can say, because it's the truth and because I think Bob would agree, that it matters who we say taught us. When Bob digs up an ant burrow and says sorry, who taught him to say it? His mother? His stepfather? The ants? I don't know. But I know who taught me, and I know that whoever it was had been taught by someone else, who had been taught by someone else, back to the beginning. That chain of teachers is what we mean by culture. And it seems to me that a book about the bush which has no chain of teachers in it has left out the most important part.

In the next chapter I'll leave the creek and follow Bob to the years when his love of animals turned into a business, and I'll look at how he got hold of the animals he put in it.


Notes

Quotations from the Irwin books (checked against `sources/`):

  • LCH Ch 1, p. 20: Les "a sturdy, incredibly tall man who was nevertheless remarkably tender, a true gentle giant"; "he always had the time to stop and show me how to do things properly"; "The Basin… tiny country town… foothills of the enchanting Dandenong Ranges in Victoria". ✔
  • LCH Ch 1, p. 21: "The Basin Primary School consisted of one room and felt just like a prison to me"; "Trapped at my desk, I couldn't wait for the hours to pass so I could race home and get back down to the creek to see what creatures I could discover"; "smallest kid in the district"; "engrossed in my own untroubled world"; "I felt at ease in my own company. I thought humans were a peculiar breed."; "If you mucked up, they bit you. But if you respected their space, they'd respect you too. It was as simple as that in the animal world and a lot more complicated when it came to humans."; "The more I observed things out in the bush, the more insatiable my appetite grew to know more. The bush became my school of life."; "vast open paddock, filled with blackberry bushes and butting up against miles and miles of dense bush that sloped down to a flowing creek"; "It was an idyllic place for a curious boy to grow up. It became my habitat, where I felt a sense of belonging."; "I'd follow every critter to see where it lived: in the hollows, in the mud, below the surface of the water"; mother: "now you can go right back where you came from and let that go again." ✔
  • LCH Ch 1, p. 22: bull ants' nest ("parked myself in the middle of a raging bull ants' nest"); "curiously observe those ants move about their bustling city for hours"; "I gloried in the bush for years and years." ✔ (The boots were cut off by his Dad, i.e. Les — "he cut them down both sides with a leather knife".) Note: in the chapter I describe it as "his stepfather's leather knife": the text says "Dad", and p. 20 says Les "was always Dad to me" — fine, but see author note below.
  • LCH Ch 1, p. 25: Steve "born… on Lyn's twentieth birthday in 1962"; p. 24: "married when Lyn was just eighteen and I was nineteen". ✔ (Birth year of Bob is not stated; my "1940s and 1950s" is an inference.)
  • LCH Author's note, p. 13 (Amanda French): ants apology; "Bob is the last of his breed of bushman. He can tie any knot, track animals by instinct, survive in the bush and tell a bloody good yarn by the fire."; "never met someone with more compassion than him, even for the tiniest little lizard." ✔
  • LCH Ch 2, p. 51: "I made a point of sitting him down and making him learn how to survive in the bush, how to orienteer by himself—all of those things the Indigenous people of this land knew by instinct. These were vital life skills to have in the bush."; "follow that body of water downstream and you'll always come out somewhere accessible." ✔
  • S&M Ch 1: Caloundra buffet; "Gosh, you aren't ladylike at all."; "I smell ducks"; "Steve, you are the most amazing bushman I've ever met"; "…a Crocodile Dundee trick that had nevertheless worked its magic on this naive American girl." ✔
  • S&M Ch 8: Steve "would sometimes wonder if I'd married him just because I loved him, or if it was because he was a bit of Tarzan and Croc Dundee and Indiana Jones all rolled…" ✔ (chapter assignment by position in text, line 728, within Chapter Eight).
  • S&M Ch 7: "In the middle of this vast landscape were the two of us, the only people for miles."; "a local cattle station about an hour-and-a-half drive from where we were filming, a small homestead in the middle of nowhere"; "The best times in my life were out in the bush with Steve." ✔

External facts:

  • The Basin (City of Knox): Wurundjeri people of the Kulin Nation are the acknowledged traditional custodians; Bunurong and others visited to hunt in summer; Wurundjeri and Bunurong Countries meet in the Dandenong Ranges. Sources: City of Knox profile (https://profile.id.com.au/knox/about); The Basin Residents' Precinct (https://thebasinrp.com.au/); Mt Evelyn History Group paper (https://www.mt-evelyn.net/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Dandenongs-Exploring-a-Volcanic-Landscape.pdf).
  • Yarra Ranges Council "Dandenong Ranges Story / Ridgewalk (ngurrak barring)": 2019 Aboriginal Cultural Values Assessment Report with Wurundjeri Woi Wurrung Cultural Heritage Aboriginal Corporation, Bunurong Land Council, Boon Wurrung Foundation; theme: "The tourist trade of the mid-20th century attracting Aboriginal entrepreneurs such as Bill Onus" (https://shaping.yarraranges.vic.gov.au/ridgewalk/dandenong-ranges-story).
  • Blackberry as an introduced weed in Australia: general knowledge, unsourced here.
  • "about sixty-five thousand years": common figure for the antiquity of Aboriginal occupation (Madjedbebe); the author may prefer "more than sixty-five thousand" or the wording he uses in speech.

⚠ Items the author should personally verify / decide:

  • "I'm not a Kulin man" — obviously true by his account; confirm he's happy to say he defers to Wurundjeri/Bunurong custodians.
  • The claim "We were taught… by our old people" — the author's voice; check it matches his own upbringing (I did not invent specifics).
  • I changed "a man in his seventies" to "an elderly man" in the body (the book doesn't state his age). "Decades later" is likewise unspecific.
  • The Bill Onus line comes from the council report summary only; I did not research where his business stood.
  • The stepfather/"Dad" detail: Bob calls Les "Dad". Consider "his father" for fidelity.
  • Opinion passages on "instinct" and the "bushman" type are framed as the author's opinion; he may sharpen or soften.