Rex reads this chapter. Tap a line to start there.

Chapter 3

"Whatever I Wanted": Collecting, Contracting and the Fauna Conservation Act

There's a paragraph in Bob Irwin's book that I admire more than almost any other. It's on page 55, in the second chapter, and it's a confession. Here it is, in full:

"The Queensland state government introduced the Fauna Conservation Act one year after we opened the park, in 1974. This formed the foundations for the start of the protection of our precious native wildlife. Before that there'd been no limit on the animals anyone could kill or capture. But as this Act came into effect and time passed, I found better ways of doing things and I became ashamed that I'd made such basic mistakes in the beginning.

>

Before the Conservation Act, anyone could pay a local contractor to catch whatever animal they wanted. I admit that I had been just as guilty of this as anybody else—up until then I'd just gone out and caught whatever I wanted to display." (The Last Crocodile Hunter, Ch. 2, p. 55)

I became ashamed. I admit that I had been just as guilty of this as anybody else.

You don't read sentences like that in the memoirs of many famous men. Most of them tell you that they were ahead of their time. Bob tells you he was of his time, and that he's embarrassed by it. I'd like to say, before I say anything critical in this chapter, that I think that's a good and decent thing to write. It's the thing I'd like a lot more people to do, about a lot more things.

So I want this chapter to be fair to him. And I also want it to ask a question that his confession doesn't ask. He says that before 1974 there was "no limit on the animals anyone could kill or capture," and that he was "just as guilty as anybody else." But who was there to put a limit on it? And whose limit counted?

How the animals got to Beerwah

First, let me set out what the book tells us about where Bob's animals came from, because it's a more interesting story than the one I'd assumed before I read it.

It begins with snakes, and it begins as a hobby. When Steve was four, Bob tells us, "I took him out to Sunbury, on the western periphery of Melbourne. I was headed there on a mission to catch eastern brown snakes. Its hilly boulder-lined paddocks with very little undergrowth supported a large population of these particular snakes. I was catching them for subcontractors to Eric Worrell, founder of the Australian Reptile Park in Gosford, who would then milk them for their venom and send it to the Commonwealth Serum Laboratories—an Australian government department researching antidotes to Australia's venomous inhabitants." (Ch. 2, p. 31)

I'd like to pause on that. This is a good thing. Bob goes on to explain that the brown snake antivenom was introduced in the mid 1950s, "it took a lot of venom milked from a lot of brown snakes to develop it," and "the antivenom would go on to save many lives" (p. 31). He's right, and I'd not want a word of this chapter to be read as a sneer at snake-catchers or antivenom. People are alive today because somebody caught those snakes. Bob adds, "Catching snakes was a hobby; I wasn't paid for it, it was just something I liked doing. I started getting to know people in the industry and made a lot of friends from whom I learnt a lot about reptiles" (p. 31).

Then there's the moment that I referred to in Chapter 1, the one that brings Bob to Beerwah. "In November 1972, on a field trip to catch snakes for snake contractors in south-east Queensland, we found the perfect three-and-a-half-acre property for sale beside the main highway in a town called Beerwah. So we bought it, and that was that" (Ch. 1, p. 35).

So here is the chain. A hobby, a paddock in Sunbury, a contractor in Gosford, a government laboratory, a field trip, a block for sale. At no point in this chain, at any link, is there a person whose Country it was. The snakes are caught on Country, sold on, milked, and turned into something that saves lives. The block is found on Country, bought, and turned into a park. The Country is there at every step, and it's never named.

I am going to be careful here, because I know that "no one asked the Traditional Owners" is the sort of thing a person can say about almost any activity in Australia in the 1960s and 70s, and it can start to sound like a reflex. So let me say exactly what I mean. I'm not saying that anyone broke a rule. As far as I can tell nobody did. What I'm saying is that there was no rule, and that the absence of the rule is the part worth thinking about. The question wasn't whether catching brown snakes on the Sunbury paddocks was legal. It was whose paddocks they were in the first place, and who, in that country, had always had the say over what was taken from it and how.

Sunbury is Country. It has Traditional Owners. I don't know which people they are in the sense of being able to speak for them, and I haven't taken the trouble to look them up for this chapter, because the book doesn't say, and the point is that the book doesn't say. A boy raised in The Basin, a father driving a four-year-old to a paddock on the edge of Melbourne to catch snakes, would not have been told. That doesn't make it his fault. It does make it a pattern.

"No limit"

Now back to the confession. I want to read it slowly, as I did with the "instinct" sentence in the last chapter, because I think it's worth it.

"Before that there'd been no limit on the animals anyone could kill or capture." Bob means, no limit in law. The Queensland Parliament hadn't passed one. If you take the sentence in its own terms, that's accurate: the Fauna Conservation Act 1974 is a real Act of the Queensland Parliament, and the Senate's own inquiry into the wildlife trade records that crocodiles were given full protection under Queensland legislation in 1974 (Parliament of Australia, Senate Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport Committee report on the commercial use of native wildlife, ch. 11). Bob is right that before that, the state law didn't stop him.

But the sentence makes a claim that I'd like to push on. "No limit" can't mean no limit of any kind, for the simple reason that the country was already full of limits. It just wasn't full of statute limits.

Let me be careful again, because this is a part of the chapter where I could easily claim too much. I'm a Kabi man, and I'll tell you what I know and not what I don't. I'm not going to set out for you here the specific rules my people had about particular animals, because those aren't mine to print in a book without the right people agreeing, and some are not for everyone to hear. But I can say, as a general matter, and I'd be astonished if any Aboriginal reader disagreed, that Aboriginal nations across this continent had law about animals. Animals were part of kinship and responsibility, and people were responsible for particular species and places. Some animals might be eaten at one time of year and left alone at another; some could be taken by some people and not others; some might not be harmed at all. This was no free-for-all. It was a system, and it had been tested over a span of time that makes the whole history of the Queensland Parliament look like a long weekend.

So when Bob says that before 1974 "there'd been no limit," what he is saying, from where I stand, is that there was no limit that his society recognised. And the next sentence tells us a bit more about what he thought was acceptable: "Reptiles, in particular, had no protection in Queensland under the legislation up until this point" (p. 55).

Under the legislation. I'd put that in the margin of the book in thick black pen. The reptiles had no protection under the legislation. They had protection under another law, a much older one, which the legislators weren't reading.

The permits

From 1974, things changed. A new system arrived, and it's worth looking closely at what it was and who it put in charge.

The book gives us two glimpses. The first is the time Bob sets out, after the Act, to get crocodiles for the park: "Under the new system, I eventually got a permit to catch five freshies to display at the reptile park" (p. 56). The second is thirteen years later, in the East Coast Crocodile Management Plan, when the government invited "expressions of interest from external subcontractors to remove from certain river systems crocodiles deemed to pose a threat to people, dogs or livestock" (Ch. 4, p. 104). "For ten dollars," Bob says, "we purchased from the department a permit to remove fauna under the Fauna Conservation Act. This was one of five permits allocated at that time. . . . We all had to supply our own equipment and manpower and there was no financial compensation whatsoever. In fact, we had to pay a royalty to the state government for every crocodile we took out of the water" (Ch. 4, p. 105).

I'd like to be completely fair about this passage. It's an honest account of a regulated activity. It shows a state department running a permit system, a small number of permits, and a royalty. It shows Bob and Steve working at their own cost. And it shows a man who was uncomfortable with the arrangement but took part in it, as he says, "to make the best of a bad situation" (p. 104). I don't criticise him for any of that.

But let me tell you what I notice about the law underneath it. The Fauna Conservation Act 1974 did something, and the text of the Act is on the public record. Section 7 declared that "All fauna, save fauna taken or kept during an open season with respect to that fauna, is the property of the Crown and under the control of the Fauna Authority" (Fauna Conservation Act 1974 (Qld), s. 7). In other words: the animals of Queensland, including the crocodiles of the Ingham creeks and the pythons and goannas Bob wanted for his park, were declared by the Queensland Parliament to belong to the Crown.

The Crown, in this context, means the government of a colony that the British made out of land they had declared to be no one's. So here's the sequence: first the land was claimed as belonging to nobody, then it was made the Crown's, then the animals on the land were made the Crown's too, and then the Crown sold permits to remove them, for ten dollars.

I don't say this to make Bob sound like a villain. In the larger story, the Crown's Act was a good thing for crocodiles. They were being shot to near-extinction. The same Senate inquiry records that the skin trade after the Second World War expanded so dramatically that by the late 1960s populations of both species "were seriously depleted," and that protection in Queensland in 1974 "allowed for a substantial recovery in numbers." I'd have signed that law myself. What I'm pointing at isn't the Act's purpose. It's its assumption: that there was no one else with a claim. That the state was the only party who could say what could be taken.

The High Court and the harpoon

And here is a thing I only learned when I was preparing this chapter, which seems to me almost too neat to be true.

In 1999 the High Court of Australia heard a case called Yanner v Eaton. Murrandoo Yanner, a Gangalidda man from the Gulf country, had killed two estuarine crocodiles with a traditional harpoon, and was charged under section 54 of the very same Fauna Conservation Act that Bob had bought his permits under. The Queensland Court of Appeal had held that his native title right to hunt had been wiped out by section 7: because the Act made all fauna the "property of the Crown," there was nothing left to hunt. The High Court disagreed. By a majority, it held that section 7 "conferred less than full, beneficial or absolute ownership" and was only a set of "rights of executive control designed to underpin the licence system," and that the Act therefore regulated but did not extinguish the native title right to hunt (Yanner v Eaton (1999) 201 CLR 351, as summarised in (2000) 5(1) Australian Indigenous Law Reporter 47).

I'm not a lawyer and I'm not going to pretend I can explain every wrinkle. But the plain meaning is this: in the same legal framework that gave a plumber from Victoria a permit for ten dollars, a man from Gangalidda Country won the right, in the highest court in the land, to harpoon a crocodile in the manner of his ancestors without anyone's permit. The same Act. The same species. Two completely different ways of being in relationship with them.

I'll come back to Yanner v Eaton in Chapter 10, because it bears on a paragraph near the end of Bob's book in which he complains about the Native Title Act. For now I'll say only that the Irwins' account of the permits is told with no awareness at all that, the whole time, there was another body of law, with another set of holders, running alongside the first.

"Out into remote areas"

There's one more detail in the confession that I want to pick up. Bob says that if he wanted "a more uncommon native species like a green python or a scrub python, I'd go out into remote areas to find them, and at the same time see where the animal lived and the kind of environment it came from, so that I could better understand the conditions I needed to provide for it back at the park" (p. 55).

That's a lovely thing to say. It's what a good keeper does. He goes to the place, sees how the animal lives, and brings back what he learns. I think it's a mark of someone who took the animals seriously.

But I'd like you to see the geography of the sentence. "Remote areas." Remote from where? From the road, from the park, from the places where Bob lived. Not from the people who lived there, who, in the north of Queensland where green pythons live, were and are numerous and well-informed. "Remote" is how it looks from the highway.

And what the sentence describes is a flow. The animal is taken from the place it lives, brought to a park near a highway, and displayed for an entrance fee. At the end of the process, a family in a car in the Sunshine Coast can look at a green python and learn what a green python is. This is, I should say, exactly how nearly every zoo in the world has worked. It's not Bob's invention. I'm not complaining that he did it. I'm asking whether the people from whose country the python came were ever consulted, or thanked, or paid. And I'm answering: not in these pages.

A growing business

From these beginnings, the park grows. By 1980, Bob says, "Beerwah Reptile Park was steadily trucking along. Every single cent that came through the front gate in takings went straight back into the running of the park. Day by day, week by week, year by year, the park continued to progress and, finally, began to turn a profit. As we became one of the Sunshine Coast's premier tourist attractions, we reached a point where we had even outgrown our name." (Ch. 3, p. 66) He and Lyn "purchased an adjoining five acres next door," doubled the park's size, and hired staff "for the first time."

I'm going to hold the money for Chapter 8, where it belongs. Here I'll only note that "every single cent . . . went straight back into the running of the park" reads, to me, as an honest and credible picture of how a small family business works. They weren't getting rich in 1980. They were scraping.

What interests me is a smaller detail from two pages later. David Fleay, whom Bob calls "my mentor and most treasured friend on the wildlife scene," was ill, and "parted ways with his thirty-seven-acre sanctuary to the Queensland government, after which it became a conservation park only displaying native wildlife in their natural environment" (p. 68). As Fleay found homes for his animals, he gave some to Bob, including "Harriet the Galapagos tortoise, at a staggering one hundred and fifty plus years of age." Harriet's history, Bob tells us, "was thought to go back to the 1830s." Fleay had first seen her at the Brisbane Botanical Gardens in 1939, bought her in the 1950s when she was put up for sale, and "it was a possibility that Harriet was brought to Australia on the HMS Beagle after being collected as a specimen by the great naturalist Charles Darwin himself" (p. 68).

I enjoy that story. But I also hear what it says about the way the animal world was passed around by the men who dealt in it: a tortoise from the Galápagos, possibly collected for science by a famous man, shipped by sea to a colony, put up for sale, bought by a friend, bequeathed to another friend, driven to Beerwah in the back of a Landcruiser. Bob says the tortoises were "often stowed as food for the sailors," flipped on their backs in the holds of ships. Animals in this story are things that move from owner to owner. I think that's an accurate picture of how the colonial world treated them. It's a picture I'd contrast with the one my people hold, in which an animal belongs to a place and a kin-group first, and to no one second.

Credit where it's due

I want to end the substantive part of this chapter with a fair reckoning, because Bob's confession deserves it.

I think that, in the matter of the animals, Bob's moral development, as he describes it, is genuine and impressive. A man who starts out catching whatever he likes and who ends up saying he's ashamed of it, who ends up joining a programme to catch and relocate "problem" crocodiles, with the stated aim of getting to them before people "took matters into their own hands" (Ch. 4, p. 104), is a man who changed. And I should be honest that crocodiles, and a lot of other animals, are alive in Australia today partly because of people like him.

I think, too, that he is right that Queensland's earlier law was a failure. A "free-for-all" was "completely unsustainable" (p. 55). It nearly finished the crocodile.

But I also think that the story he tells, of an honest man's journey from ignorance to responsibility, is the story of a man discovering the government's idea of what responsibility is. He found "better ways of doing things." He learned what the "authorities" wanted. He joined "a new way of operating." And in all that learning, there was an entire other body of knowledge about how to treat the animals of this continent, held by the people who'd been treating them well for tens of thousands of years, and it never comes into the frame.

Here's the way I'd put it as an opinion. The moral of Bob's confession is true. It's also incomplete. If we're going to talk about the protection of our "precious native wildlife," as he calls it, we should talk about who protected it first.

What I'd like the reader to take from this chapter

  • That Bob Irwin did something rare and good when he wrote that he was "ashamed."
  • That it's possible to be ashamed of the right thing and still not see the whole thing.
  • That the legal framework that gave Bob his permits was a framework in which the state declared the animals to be the Crown's, and that this framework was later held, in the Yanner case, not to have wiped out the older rights of Aboriginal people to hunt.
  • That a book about wildlife protection which doesn't mention that Aboriginal people had law about animals is describing the history of the licence, not the history of the protection.

In the next chapter I'll go through the passages where Aboriginal people do appear in the two books, slowly and with respect, because they deserve to be read properly.


Notes

Quotations from the Irwin books (checked against `sources/`; page = PDF page):

  • LCH Ch 2, p. 31: Sunbury / eastern brown snakes / "subcontractors to Eric Worrell, founder of the Australian Reptile Park in Gosford… Commonwealth Serum Laboratories"; "The brown snake antivenom had only been around ten years or so then. It had been introduced in the mid 1950s, and it took a lot of venom milked from a lot of brown snakes…"; "the antivenom would go on to save many lives"; "Catching snakes was a hobby; I wasn't paid for it…" ✔ (Steve "just four years old".)
  • LCH Ch 1, p. 35: Nov 1972 purchase ✔.
  • LCH Ch 2, p. 55: Fauna Conservation Act "one year after we opened the park, in 1974"; "no limit on the animals anyone could kill or capture"; "I became ashamed that I'd made such basic mistakes in the beginning"; "Before the Conservation Act, anyone could pay a local contractor…"; "I admit that I had been just as guilty…"; "just gone out and caught whatever I wanted to display"; "remote areas… green python or a scrub python… see where the animal lived…"; "completely unsustainable… laissez-faire attitude… the norm"; "Reptiles, in particular, had no protection in Queensland under the legislation up until this point." ✔
  • LCH Ch 2, p. 56: "Under the new system, I eventually got a permit to catch five freshies to display at the reptile park." ✔
  • LCH Ch 4, p. 104: East Coast Crocodile Management Plan (1987), "expressions of interest from external subcontractors to remove from certain river systems crocodiles deemed to pose a threat to people, dogs or livestock"; "to make the best of a bad situation" ✔. p. 105: "For ten dollars, we purchased from the department a permit to remove fauna under the Fauna Conservation Act. This was one of five permits allocated at that time."; "no financial compensation whatsoever. In fact, we had to pay a royalty to the state government for every crocodile we took out of the water." ✔
  • LCH Ch 3, p. 66: 1980 rebrand; "Every single cent that came through the front gate in takings went straight back into the running of the park"; "began to turn a profit"; "one of the Sunshine Coast's premier tourist attractions"; adjoining five acres; staff "for the first time". ✔
  • LCH Ch 3, p. 68: David Fleay "my mentor and most treasured friend on the wildlife scene"; "parted ways with his thirty-seven-acre sanctuary to the Queensland government…"; Harriet; "It was a possibility that Harriet was brought to Australia on the HMS Beagle…"; "Tortoises were often stowed as food for the sailors". ✔ (Quotes abridged with ellipses; the "stowed as food" quote is of the whole phrase "often stowed as food for the sailors".)

External sources:

  • Fauna Conservation Act 1974 (Qld), reprint 1 July 1981, s. 6 (classes of fauna), s. 7 "Property in fauna": "All fauna, save fauna taken or kept during an open season with respect to that fauna, is the property of the Crown and under the control of the Fauna Authority." https://digitalcollections.qut.edu.au/2501/1/qsr_fauna_conservation_act_1974_1jul81.pdf ✔
  • Senate Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee, report on commercial utilisation of Australian native wildlife, ch. 11 "Crocodiles": post-war skin trade; by late 1960s both species "seriously depleted"; "full protection under state legislation (in 1962 in Western Australia, 1964 in Northern Territory, and 1974 in Queensland)"; protection "allowed for a substantial recovery in numbers". https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Rural_and_Regional_Affairs_and_Transport/Completed_inquiries/Pre_1999/wild/report/c11 ✔ (I cited the report generally as "ch. 11"; verify the report's full title before print — I wrote "Commercial utilisation of Australian native wildlife" from memory of the inquiry's name; the URL path ends "…/wild/report/c11".)
  • Yanner v Eaton (1999) 201 CLR 351 (HCA): Murrandoo Yanner, Gangalidda man, killed two estuarine crocodiles with a traditional harpoon; charged under s 54(1)(a) Fauna Conservation Act 1974 (Qld); Qld Court of Appeal held native title hunting right extinguished by s 7; High Court allowed appeal by majority, holding s 7 "conferred less than full, beneficial or absolute ownership" and was "no more than the aggregate of a series of rights of executive control designed to underpin the licence system"; the Act regulated but did not extinguish native title. Source: Australian Indigenous Law Reporter case summary (https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/journals/AUIndigLawRpr/2000/5.html); High Court page (https://www.hcourt.gov.au/cases-and-judgments/judgments/judgments-1998-current/yanner-v-eaton). The quoted phrases are from the ILR summary of the judgment. The decision year (1999) and citation (201 CLR 351) are from my own knowledge — verify before print.

⚠ Items the author should personally verify / decide:

  • Sunbury: I deliberately named no Traditional Owners.
  • "The whole history of the Queensland Parliament looks like a long weekend" — rhetorical.
  • The paragraph about Aboriginal law about animals is general, not Kabi-specific, and is the author's view — confirm he is comfortable; he may wish to add one example that is his to tell.
  • "I'd have signed that law myself" — an author-voice opinion.
  • Statement that the Crown is "the government of a colony that the British made out of land they had declared to be no one's" is the author's position (see Introduction notes on terra nullius).
  • The text says Bob joined a relocation programme; "took matters into their own hands" is from LCH Ch 4, p. 104 ✔.
  • "who, in the north of Queensland where green pythons live, were and are numerous and well-informed": a general statement, not sourced.