There's one passage in The Last Crocodile Hunter that I knew I'd have to write about from the first time I read it. It's short. It sits in the middle of a long list of the campaigns Bob joined after Steve died, between the Great Barrier Reef and the trophy hunters. It's the only place in either book, as far as I can find, where Aboriginal people appear as the subject of a complaint.
Here it is, whole:
"I fought hammer and tongs alongside a steadfast individual called Colin 'Who Cares' Riddell to highlight the need for change to the Native Title Act which allows the slaughter of endangered dugongs and sea turtles. Dugongs were being drowned slowly as well as cut up while they were still alive, and our precious sea turtles were being left upside down on beaches to die from dehydration. Cruelty is cruelty; it isn't a matter of race. As a result of Colin's tireless work, the Native Title Act was changed to include Indigenous people in regards to laws governing animal cruelty." (LCH Ch. 14, pp. 253–254)
I've read those four sentences many times. I want to be fair to them, because there's something in them I agree with, and something I think is wrong, and the two things are tangled together. So I'll go slowly.
What's right
Cruelty is cruelty. Nobody should defend an animal being cut up alive, and nobody I've ever met in my own community would. I'll say so plainly, so that nobody can say I dodged. If what Bob describes is happening, it should be stopped.
I also want to be clear that Bob is, on this subject, consistent. Look at what he says about other people. About trophy hunting: "I find it difficult to understand how anybody could get any pleasure or satisfaction from killing an animal, full stop" (p. 254). About the crocodile-farming industry: "I have always been vehemently against this industry, because I believe we shouldn't farm and destroy any native wildlife for profit… I don't care whether it's crocodiles, kangaroos or emus, I don't think we have the moral right" (Ch. 4, p. 100). About coal seam gas, he was arrested at a protest and, after refusing to sign a promise not to return, was fined four hundred dollars (Ch. 14, pp. 251–252). He applies the same rule to farmers, trophy hunters, miners and governments. When Bob says "it isn't a matter of race," I believe he means: I hold everyone to the same standard.
That's a respectable thing to mean. And I don't think Bob's heart is in the wrong place on the animals. A man who has spent his life working with crocodiles has earned the right to be angry about cruelty.
And let me be fair about one more thing. Aboriginal people are not on the other side of this. In September 2017 the Senate debated the issue of dugongs and turtles in northern Australia, after Senator Derryn Hinch, who, in his speech, named Colin Riddell and Bob Irwin as "champions of wildlife," described what he'd seen. One of the senators who spoke was Malarndirri McCarthy, a Yanyuwa woman from the Gulf Country. She said:
"But there is no room for the desecration and the incredible cruelty that we've seen at different stages over the years. The penalties that are there should apply. Clearly, if you break the law, those penalties need to apply."
And she said: "there is great sadness at even the death of one dugong. If that dugong is there and has been cut to feed the family, there is sorrow with that." She described how, in her own clan, when a hunter brings a dugong back to land, "the dugong is turned to face towards the sea. Again, there is a blessing that goes with how that dugong not only has just been caught but is about to be killed to feed the clan and the family group that are gathered…" She added: "Believe me, [the question of what's traditional and what's contemporary] is an ongoing conversation that takes place, even within our own families across Australia, as first nations people" (Senate, 13 September 2017).
I quote her at length for one reason. The picture in Bob's paragraph is of two sides: people who love animals, and Aboriginal people who kill them. But an Aboriginal senator is on the record saying that cruelty has no place, that the law should be enforced, and that in her own family's tradition the death of an animal is the occasion for a blessing. And she, too, knows young men with fast boats can do the wrong thing, and that Aboriginal people argue about it among themselves.
What I think is wrong
Now the other part. I'll go through it in four steps.
One: the Act doesn't "allow the slaughter."
Bob says the Native Title Act "allows the slaughter of endangered dugongs and sea turtles." As I understand the law, and I'm not a lawyer, that's not quite how it works. The Native Title Act (Cth) 1993 has a section, s. 211, which says that where a law would otherwise require a licence or permit to hunt, fish or gather, native title holders don't need one if they're doing it for their "personal, domestic or non-commercial communal needs" and in exercise of their native title rights. That is the section at issue in Yanner v Eaton (1999) 201 CLR 351, which I discussed in Chapter 3, where the High Court decided that Murrandoo Yanner, a Gangalidda man from the Gulf Country, could not be convicted under Queensland's Fauna Conservation Act for harpooning two estuarine crocodiles, because of his native title right.
Note what that is about: licensing. It's about whether the Crown can say "you need a permit from us to do what your people have always done." It isn't, on its face, about cruelty. The Native Title Act doesn't say "Aboriginal people may torture animals." It says, roughly, "the Crown's licensing system doesn't switch off older rights." Whether a given hunt was cruel is a separate matter, and in Queensland the animal-welfare law, the *Animal Care and Protection Act 2001*, would be where you'd look.
Two: the Act wasn't "changed" the way Bob says, as far as I can find.
Bob says: "As a result of Colin's tireless work, the Native Title Act was changed to include Indigenous people in regards to laws governing animal cruelty."
I looked. What I found is a different law. In September 2012 the Queensland Parliament debated the Animal Care and Protection and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2012. The minister, Glen Elmes, told Parliament that the Bill was about "the cruel treatment of turtles and dugong" and the "commercial killing of these animals." He said: "Let me make it very clear from the outset that I am not trying to curtail traditional hunting by Indigenous people which is permitted under native title. This bill supports traditional hunting practices but seeks to ensure they are carried out as humanely as possible and that the product of that hunting is used for local people, for their community or for ceremonial use." After consultation with Indigenous communities, he said, the proposed amnesty before enforcement had been doubled "from six to 12 months" (Queensland Hansard, 12 September 2012).
So, on what I've seen: the change was to a Queensland animal-welfare law, not the federal Native Title Act, and it was framed by its own minister as preserving native title hunting, with conditions about humane methods and non-commercial use. That may well be what Bob means, in the loose way people talk about these things. I can't tell. But I'd say to the author of the paragraph, and to the publisher, that the sentence as written is not accurate, and in this particular area, where the law matters, the inaccuracy matters.
(I should be clear that I haven't read the final Act, only the minister's speech, and I'm not certain it passed in the form debated. Please verify before print.)
Three: "it isn't a matter of race" gets the issue backwards.
Here's where I think the sentence does its real damage.
The right Bob is objecting to is not a race-based right. It isn't a right that Aboriginal people have because of the colour of their skin. It's a right that comes from being the people who were here, and who had, and still have, laws of their own. Native title is the law's recognition of that. When the High Court said in Mabo (No 2) that the common law recognises native title, it didn't say that Aboriginal people are special. It said that they had been here first, with their own system of law, and that the arrival of British sovereignty didn't automatically erase it.
So "isn't a matter of race" is true, but not in the way it's meant. The reason Aboriginal people can hunt dugong under native title is not their race. It's their law, which is older than the Crown's. A man who says, "we should all be treated the same," is saying something that sounds like justice but has a hidden assumption: that the starting point is the same for everybody. It isn't. One group's law was here when the other group's law arrived.
Bob's own paragraph shows it, because look at what he did in the 1970s. In Chapter 3, I described the permits he got under the Fauna Conservation Act, the Crown's law, which declared all wildlife the property of the Crown. A man who has the Crown's permit to catch crocodiles in a river is, in the end, exercising a right given to him by the Crown. A Gangalidda man with a harpoon is exercising a right that was never given to him by anyone. These aren't the same, and treating them as the same is itself a choice, one that favours the later law.
Four: it makes a problem out of one group.
The list of campaigns in this chapter of Bob's book runs to more than a page: coal seam gas, cassowaries after Cyclone Yasi, the Traveston Crossing Dam, whales, koalas, the Great Barrier Reef dredging, dugongs and turtles, trophy hunting of crocodiles. In most of them the targets are governments, companies, or developers. In the dugong paragraph, the ones named as responsible are the people with native title. And that paragraph is the only place in this whole chapter of Bob's book where Aboriginal or Indigenous people are mentioned.
I don't think Bob did this out of malice. I think he saw photographs and heard accounts that horrified him, and he did what he does, which is to charge in on behalf of the animals. But I notice what the reader is left with: in a whole book, the only Aboriginal people who walk into the story as a group are the ones who, in one sentence, are described as the people who slaughter dugongs.
What the evidence says
I want to be careful here, and a bit humble, because I'm not a marine biologist.
The 2017 Senate debate is revealing for what it shows about the dispute. Senator Hinch described, among other things, young men with fast boats and machetes, and, of some of his figures, said "I can't vouch for this to be true." He and others described photographs. Government ministers and senators on the other side said something different. The Minister for Indigenous Affairs, Nigel Scullion, said: "the overall impact of traditional hunting on turtle and dugong populations is small. The main impacts on populations are, in fact, from other areas": marine debris, especially gillnets, habitat, feral pigs digging up turtle nests. Another senator said that a two-year Australian Crime Intelligence Commission investigation had found no substantive evidence of an organised commercial trade in turtle and dugong meat, though she added that she hadn't seen the report itself. Another, Senator Cory Bernardi, who said he was undecided, put the opposite view: that "modern technology" such as outboard motors undermines "an ancient tribal right"; I mention his words so that you can see it's not one-sided.
I'm not going to tell you who's right. Some of it is probably true on both sides. What I can say is that the evidence isn't as one-sided as Bob's paragraph. He says the right "allows the slaughter" of endangered animals. The government's own position, as put by its ministers in 2017, was that traditional hunting was a small contributor to the decline compared with nets, debris and development. A paragraph that says "slaughter" but doesn't mention nets or plastic or the fact that Aboriginal rangers are on the frontline of protecting these animals is not a balanced one. (In the debate, several senators praised the Indigenous ranger programs, and Senator McCarthy described the Li-Anthawirriyarra Sea Rangers coming "down hard on anyone, Indigenous or otherwise, who is doing the wrong thing.")
The bigger inconsistency
There's something I find striking, and I think Bob would, too, if I put it to him.
Bob says, of crocodiles, in his own book: "While Aboriginal people had long hunted crocodiles for their meat using traditional methods, the impact of hunting on crocodile populations had been minimal until the advent of .303 rifles in the 1940s" (Ch. 4, p. 99). I quoted that sentence in Chapter 4. It's an honest observation, and it's the opposite of the dugong paragraph. In one place, Bob says that traditional Aboriginal hunting of crocodiles had a minimal effect for as long as it was traditional, and that the damage began with the rifle, and the skin trade, and white hunters. In the other he says that the native title right is the problem.
Both can't be the whole truth. I'd say the first is closer to it. Traditional law doesn't mean unlimited take. It usually means the opposite: rules about who may hunt, when, how, how much, and what you must do afterwards. Senator McCarthy's description of the dugong being turned to face the sea is one example, and I won't pretend to know any of the equivalent rules of my own people. What it suggests to me is that the problem Bob saw in photographs, the boats and the machetes, may be a problem of breakdown in that law, a thing that elders themselves complain about, as McCarthy says, and not a feature of it.
And that suggests what the solution is.
What I think would work
I don't have the expertise to design a policy, and I won't pretend. But the Senate debate itself points in a direction that's very different from "change the law to stop them."
- Traditional Owners at the table. In the same debate Senator Claire Moore said that under the Great Barrier Reef's "Traditional Use of Marine Resources Agreements," "traditional owner groups work in partnership with the Australian and Queensland governments to manage traditional-use activities on their sea country." Senator Fierravanti-Wells said that in June 2016 "the traditional owners near Cairns agreed to no take of turtles and dugongs in three areas around Green Island, Michaelmas Cay and Fitzroy Island." In other words, in at least one place, the people who hold the right have chosen to limit it themselves.
- Rangers. Several senators, from several parties, said the best protection of dugongs and turtles is paying Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander rangers to look after their own sea country. That's where I'd put the money.
- Enforcement of the animal-cruelty law against anyone who breaks it. Which is what Senator McCarthy said.
None of this would have been possible if the right to hunt were abolished. It's possible because the right is recognised, which gives the holders the standing to agree to limits.
That's a story I'd love to have seen in the Irwin book. The Irwin family are brilliant at telling stories about people who work with local communities. Bob himself writes warmly about the people of Mission Beach feeding cassowaries after the cyclone: "What struck me most was the dedication of the local community" (p. 253). It's a pity the same warmth didn't extend to the Traditional Owners who, in places like the Great Barrier Reef, have been doing the same work.
The Mary Valley, again
The line just above the dugong paragraph is the one I wrote about in Chapter 4: Bob "joined forces with the people of the Mary Valley" against the Traveston Crossing Dam (p. 253). I won't repeat what I said there, except to say that it's a pattern. When the Mary Valley's farmers and residents stand against a dam, Bob names them as "the people of the Mary Valley." When Aboriginal people appear a few lines later, it is as a legal problem. The Traditional Owners of the valley were also there in that fight, but you'd never know it from this page.
What I'd say to Bob
If I could put one sentence in front of Bob, it would be this one. It's a version of his own.
*Cruelty is cruelty, and it isn't a matter of race. But who gets to decide how to stop it is a matter of law, and the law says the people who've held these animals in their care for thousands of years have a say.*
I don't think Bob and I disagree about dugongs. I think we disagree about who gets to be in the room.
In the next chapter I turn to words, the Aboriginal and non-English words that appear in the Irwin books, and what it means that some of them come with no name attached.