I'm going to start this chapter with praise, because the praise is real, and because the criticism that follows will make more sense if you can see how much I'm giving.
Bob and Steve and Terri Irwin put an astonishing amount of money and work into buying land and leaving it alone. They didn't do it for a tax deduction or a view. They did it because they'd watched what clearing does to a place, and they decided that the best thing a person with money could do was buy a piece of country and let it grow back.
Here's what the books say they did.
- Ironbark Station. Bob moved there in January 2000 "just outside of Blackbutt," in the South Burnett, "where the east coast meets the dry west at the Great Dividing Range," and says it "was to be a pilot project, where he [Steve] hoped to turn private land into regenerated areas for wildlife, similar to the model of our national parks" (LCH Ch. 6, p. 150–151). Bob says his job was to "build the property infrastructure on the sparse block." Terri, in her book, says the land was "cattle-ravaged" when they bought it, and that Steve planted "dozens, then hundreds, and finally thousands" of eucalypts, saying, "It will take a lifetime to establish these trees. But one day they will be big, they will have hollows, and there will be a place where animals can live again" (S&M Ch. 13).
- Mourachan. Bob writes that Steve "purchased around 84,000 acres out there to protect and restore as wildlife habitat" near St George, in southwest Queensland, in "the area known as the Brigalow Belt," which "had been a vital habitat for many species before widespread clearing for sheep and cattle farming had driven them to become locally extinct" (LCH Ch. 8, p. 169).
- Tasmania. Terri describes a conservation property bought in part because "we did not want to see the Tasmanian devil go the way of the thylacine," with the words, "We had purchased eighty thousand acres to help protect this fragile environment" (S&M Ch. 15).
- Cape York. "We found an area of 320,000 acres in Cape York Peninsula, bordered on one side by the Dulcie River and on the other side by the Wenlock River… Prime Minister John Howard, along with the Queensland government, dedicated $6.3 million to obtaining this land, in memory of Steve. On July 22, 2007, the Steve Irwin Wildlife Reserve became official" (S&M Ch. 19).
- Bob's own block. In 2008, after leaving Australia Zoo, Bob and his wife Judy bought 640 acres near Kingaroy because they "wanted somewhere that wasn't totally destroyed by land clearing" (LCH Ch. 13, p. 235).
That's a very large part of the continent for one family and its zoo. It's a bigger conservation footprint than most governments manage, and I would be a fool to wave it away. I'll say at once that Bob's sentences about land clearing are the ones I'm most likely to agree with. He writes: "Australia's mammalian extinction rate had fast become the worst in the world by far. No other country could even compare to the damage we'd managed to inflict in the very short time since European occupation" (LCH Ch. 8, p. 169). And he adds, a little later, something I think is wise: "A lot of land-clearing may well be inevitable to support our country's population, but we have to weigh up how we're going to manage it so that progress doesn't devastate our environment" (pp. 169–170).
I agree with every word of that. Now let me tell you what I notice in it.
"Since European occupation"
Read that sentence again. The damage we'd managed to inflict in the very short time since European occupation.
Bob doesn't say "since European settlement," the word most Australians reach for. He says occupation. I think he used it casually. But words have meanings, and "occupation" is what you call it when people arrive in a place that was already occupied. Bob's own sentence says there was a place, and it was taken up by Europeans.
And the sentence does something else. It puts a line in time. On one side of that line there's a continent that, whatever else you might say about it, still had its mammals. On the other side there's the worst extinction rate in the world. The line is drawn at the arrival of people from Britain, "the very short time" since then.
Now here's my opinion, and I want to be careful to say it's an opinion. I think Bob has, without quite meaning to, made an argument for the people who were here before the line. Australia had human beings on it for a very long time, with the commonly cited figure from the Madjedbebe excavation in Kakadu being at least 65,000 years (Clarkson and others, Nature, 2017). For all of that time, the animals that Bob and Steve and Terri want to protect lived alongside people. They didn't vanish in the "very short time" of the last two hundred and some years because of something their neighbours had been doing for sixty-five thousand.
That's not the same as saying Aboriginal people did nothing to the environment. Scientists argue about megafauna, and about fire, and I'm not going to wade into that. I'm saying that if your whole project is "a model of habitat acquisition, reforestation and maintenance for the benefit of wildlife and their wild places" (LCH p. 169), you've invented, or rather reinvented, something that Aboriginal land management had been doing for a very long time, at a scale that dwarfs even 84,000 acres. The Irwins bought what they needed to bring back a bush that had been "ravaged." Somebody, surely, had once kept it from being ravaged.
I can't tell you who. I haven't researched the Country at Blackbutt, or at St George, or at Kingaroy, and the books don't say. I mention this because I think a reader who's honest has to ask: whose bush was being bought back? A person doesn't buy back what was never theirs.
What "buying" means
Let me take that last phrase seriously, because it's more than a pun.
In the Irwin books, land is purchased. The word runs through both of them: "purchased," "bought," "secure more land," "negotiating for an additional five hundred acres." Terri writes: "We would secure more land. I remember the first two acres we ever bought to enlarge the zoo, how Steve and I sat with our arms around each other, looking at the property next door and dreaming" (S&M Ch. 19). It's a lovely image of two people dreaming. And what they're dreaming of is more acres.
I understand that. In Australian law, if you want to protect land, buying it is, for a private person, the main tool you've got. I don't blame the Irwins for using the tool. But I want to say something about what the tool assumes. It assumes that land is a thing that is owned, that it can be bought from one person and held by another, and that the person who holds the title decides what happens on it.
That's a view of land. It's a perfectly legitimate view, and it happens to be the English one. Kabi Kabi people didn't think that way, and many Aboriginal people don't. In our law, and I'll say plainly that I'm describing this in a general way, not as an authority, you belong to the land, and the land does not belong to you. You're a caretaker. You can't sell Country, because it isn't yours to sell. The Irwins' conservation dream, which is a beautiful one, was fulfilled using a system that treats land as property. And the books never mention that this is a particular way of looking at land, or that other ways exist.
I should be fair about the law. Native title is real, and the High Court made it so in Mabo (No 2) in 1992. A freehold title, though, will typically extinguish native title, while other kinds of land tenure may let it survive. The High Court held in the Wik case in 1996 that the grant of a pastoral lease didn't necessarily extinguish native title, and that the two interests might coexist. (Please treat this as a layman's summary and check it before print; I'm not a lawyer.) I mention it because a great deal of the land the Irwins bought was, as the books say, once cattle and sheep country. I don't know whether any of it carries native title. The books don't tell you. And that, again, is the point: the books never ask.
The reserve at Cape York
I need to talk about one purchase in particular, because it's the one where I found there was something on the public record, and where I want to be most careful.
Terri's book says the Steve Irwin Wildlife Reserve was bought with Commonwealth and Queensland money, $6.3 million, as a memorial to Steve. She says, "Ultimately, it meant the protection of his crocodiles, the animals he loved so much" (S&M Ch. 19). The Australia Zoo website says that the reserve was formerly Bertiehaugh Station, a cattle property, and that after Steve's death "the Australian Government purchased the Bertiehaugh Cattle Station as a living memorial," with the Irwin family and Australia Zoo taking "on the role of management of the reserve under the Australian Government's National Reserves System."
So, as I understand it, this was public money, the property of the Australian government, managed by the Irwins. Not their own land. I'd gently note, for the record, that Bob, in his book, never mentions the reserve at all by that name. The only "wildlife reserve" in his pages is the line from a wildlife carer at Ironbark about "one of his wildlife reserves somewhere out near Blackbutt" (LCH Ch. 7, p. 160).
Now here's what Terri's book also doesn't mention. In S&M and LCH I searched for the words "Traditional Owner," "Kaanju," "Mapoon," "Land Council," "ILUA," and "Bertiehaugh," and none appears in either book. But people who live on and belong to that part of Cape York have spoken publicly about the reserve, and I'm going to quote what they said, and what the reserve's staff said back, because both sides belong in the record.
In September 2013 the ABC reported that Cape York traditional owners were "frustrated with the lack of progress in reaching an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA) over parts of the Steve Irwin Wildlife Reserve." Atambaye traditional owner Gina Nona said a site there was important "because it includes remains from a massacre more than 100 years ago, but elders are being denied access." She was quoted: "We've asked already what we wanted to see what's happening there, like we want to have access to go in the area and we can't at the moment because it's got a padlock on the gate." Atambaye traditional owner Walter Moses said traditional owners "were promised access to the reserve when it was handed to the Irwin family more than six years ago but it is yet to happen." He said, "There's a man Dreaming and there's a woman birth place and there's a sacred site too, burial ground."
The ranger in charge of the reserve, Barry Lyon, was quoted in the same report. He "denies traditional owners are not allowed access to the area." He said: "Not only do we encourage traditional owners to come on the reserve, we have traditional owners actively involved in fire management, wildlife research, cultural site surveys and management… so no-one's been locked out." He said that he was "keen to see an ILUA finalised," and that the delay was a matter for the Cape York Land Council. The report also said that the Planning and Environment Court had yet to rule on the Cape York Land Council's bid to overturn the State Government's nature refuge declaration over part of the reserve (ABC News, 13 September 2013).
There's also a document that Australia Zoo lodged in response to a parliamentary inquiry, which I found when I was looking. It says that since the reserve was declared in August 2007, the zoo "has been working towards developing an 'Indigenous Land Use Agreement' with the Traditional Owners," and lists a training memorandum with the Queensland Government for Indigenous Wild River Rangers, work with Mapoon Aboriginal Rangers, crocodile-capture training with Kaanju rangers, and the "employment initially of a Tepathigghi Traditional Owner as a Ranger" on the reserve.
I am not going to judge that dispute. I don't know the Country, I wasn't there, and the report is from 2013, so I can't tell you what the position is today. Two things can be true. The reserve's staff can sincerely have worked with Aboriginal people, and Aboriginal people can sincerely have felt kept out. I've also seen how complicated agreements like these are, with different groups, different claims, and a State agency in the middle. It isn't always the fault of the person with the keys.
But I'll say what I think is clear, and it's about the books, not the reserve.
The books say nothing. In 2007, when Terri wrote about the reserve, she wrote: "It was one of the top spots in Australia, and the most critically important habitat in the state of Queensland… Ultimately, it meant the protection of his crocodiles." That's all. For a reserve of 320,000 acres of Cape York country that has Traditional Owners, not one word of acknowledgement in a book that will be read by millions of people. And Bob's 2016 book, a decade later, after that dispute had been reported publicly, says nothing about the reserve at all.
If I were a Traditional Owner of that country reading Terri's account, I would notice that.
The question I'm asking
Let me say why I've spent so long on this.
Land buying is the form the Irwins' love of the bush took. It was brave and expensive and it saved animals. But it is also, whether the buyers intended it or not, a way of making a claim: this country is now looked after by us. And whenever anyone makes that claim about land that has people who belong to it, the first and obvious question is: what about them?
It's not a hostile question. It's the question you'd ask of any conservation group, any government, any mining company. The Cape York example shows that it's not a hypothetical one. In that one place, on the public record, there were people saying they couldn't get in to look after their own burial grounds, and a staff member saying they could, and an agreement that hadn't been finished. The answer to that question is not in either book. It isn't even asked.
A different model
I've said I'd keep my criticism constructive. So let me describe what I'd put in its place, as a layman.
Start with the people. Before you buy a station, find out whose Country it is. Not afterwards, not when the paperwork's done. Beforehand, at the beginning, when you're "sitting with your arms around each other, looking at the property next door and dreaming." Invite the Traditional Owners into the dream.
Don't treat it as a purchase. If a conservation group buys land in a place where native title has been claimed or determined, the first question should be who's going to hold it in the long run. In Chapter 6 I described Rinyirru (Lakefield), which was handed back to Aboriginal freehold in 2011 and is now run jointly by Traditional Owners and the Parks service. That's a model that already exists. It's possible to have a national park, a conservation estate, and Aboriginal ownership, all at once.
Put it in the book. If the Irwins were running a reserve in partnership with Traditional Owners, that is a good news story, and a better one than the story of a family doing it alone. If they weren't yet, say so, and say what's planned. A reader deserves to know.
Pay for the knowledge. In a long project to restore a bush, the people who held that bush's knowledge for sixty-five thousand years are the best scientists on offer. They should be employed and paid as such.
None of this is an attack. It's an invitation, and one the Irwin family can still accept.
One more thing about "buying back"
I called this chapter "Buying Back the Bush" and I want to be honest about what I meant. I meant something a little sad.
Steve and Terri and Bob saw a continent where the bush had been cut down, and what they did about it was buy back bits of it, one block at a time, at market price, from other settlers. That's what a person with money can do in a country where everything has been sold. I understand why they did it.
But for me, as a Kabi man, I read "buying back the bush" and I think: we didn't sell it. Nobody asked us. The real "buying back," the one that I'd like to see, is when the people who were here first get the chance to hold their own Country, with the help of anyone who's willing. A conservation story that includes that would be a bigger one than "Steve bought some acres." It would be the best Irwin story of all.
In the next chapter I'll turn to the one place in the Irwin books where Aboriginal people appear as a problem, and where Bob says, in so many words, that the law should not treat them differently from anyone else.