I want to start with a number: forty cents.
That's what it cost an adult to get in on the first day. Bob Irwin tells us so in The Last Crocodile Hunter: "Gate entry was just forty cents for adults and twenty cents for children. And we were happier than pigs in mud" (Ch. 2, p. 39). Terri repeats the figure in Steve & Me, thinking back to "what it must have been like when Lyn first started the zoo. It was just a small wildlife park, with admission only forty cents for adults and twenty cents for kids" (Ch. 13).
I like that number. It's honest. It's a small, plain, human number, and it says something I believe about the beginning of this story: it was a family with a shed and a snake collection and a hand-painted mural of a brown snake on the front fence, hoping that a few people would walk in off the road. Bob built the ticket office himself. He tells us that he "toiled away in the shed at night, cutting information signs out of pieces of metal and painting them" (p. 39). The first newspaper advertisement read, in his words, "Stop! You can't go past without calling in to see one of Australia's largest collections of native reptiles at Beerwah Reptile Park. Hop in!" (Ch. 2, p. 38).
I'm not going to be sneery about any of that. Starting a business with your hands, your savings and your kids is hard, and I have enormous respect for people who do it. Bob sold the family home and a beach house and a car he loved. "The sacrifices were coming hard and fast as we faced the realities of following our dream" (Ch. 2, p. 36). I'm sure that's true. Opening day was 11 April 1973, and he says there was no grand opening; they just opened the gates (p. 38).
This chapter is about what happened to that forty cents. Not in a gossipy way. I'm not interested in anyone's bank balance, and I'll say plainly that I don't know the zoo's finances and wouldn't comment on them if I did. I'm interested in the shape of the story the two books tell about the business, and in one question that neither book asks: what does it mean to build a successful business on a piece of Country, and say nothing, in your own account of it, about whose Country it is?
The size of it
Let me lay out the growth, using only what the books say.
- 1973. Beerwah Reptile Park opens on a three-and-a-half-acre block (LCH Ch. 2, pp. 37–38).
- By 1980. "Beerwah Reptile Park was steadily trucking along. Every single cent that came through the front gate in takings went straight back into the running of the park… finally, began to turn a profit. As we became one of the Sunshine Coast's premier tourist attractions, we reached a point where we had even outgrown our name" (LCH Ch. 3, p. 66). They bought an adjoining five acres.
- Terri's early years, from the early 1990s. "We judged it a good Sunday if we had one hundred visitors, perhaps six hundred and fifty dollars in gross receipts" (S&M Ch. 6). Terri was, in her words, "the one-woman marketing department for the zoo. My budget was twelve hundred dollars for the whole year" (S&M Ch. 6).
- Later. A "five-thousand-seat Crocoseum" where the croc show ran twice a day, "seven days a week, every single day of the year" (LCH Ch. 11, p. 211). Terri says Steve's budget for the arena was "somewhere north of eight million dollars, a huge expense" (S&M Ch. 15).
- 2007. The Steve Irwin Wildlife Reserve, 320,000 acres in Cape York, to which "Prime Minister John Howard, along with the Queensland government, dedicated $6.3 million" (S&M Ch. 19).
Forty cents; six hundred and fifty dollars; eight million; six point three million. Whatever else you think about the Irwins, the books describe an extraordinary rise, and the people who built it worked brutally hard. Terri tells us that Steve "worked from dawn until well after dark, when he rigged spotlights to be able to keep working," and that "often I'd catch him throwing up behind a tree out of sheer physical exhaustion" (S&M Ch. 6). I believe it. It's a good story about work.
The name
Now I want to look at something Bob mentions in a few lines, which I find quite striking.
In 1980 or thereabouts, he says, the park had grown so much that "we had even outgrown our name. We decided it was time to rebrand the business to better represent what our little family park had evolved into. As a family, we settled on the name Queensland Reptile and Fauna Park. Beerwah was suddenly too limiting, and we had established more than just a collection of reptiles" (LCH Ch. 3, p. 66).
Then, in Terri's account, when she and Steve took over from Steve's parents: "The new name would be simply Australia Zoo" (S&M Ch. 6).
So the name went from a mountain, to a state, to a country. Beerwah. Queensland. Australia.
I want to be careful here, because I can already hear someone saying that I'm making too much of it. Bob's explanation is perfectly clear: "Beerwah" in the name of a reptile park was too narrow, because the park now held mammals and birds. Names change when businesses grow. That's ordinary. I'm not suggesting that Bob chose to erase the mountain, or that he was thinking about the mountain at all.
What I will say, and I'll flag it as my opinion, is that the sentence "Beerwah was suddenly too limiting" is a revealing one. It treats the name of the place as a limit. A name that tells you where you are, in your own language, is a thing you outgrow. A name that tells you what you're for, a zoo, a nation's zoo, is a thing you grow into. For people who belong to a place, the name Beerwah is not a limitation. It's an address. It says who you are and who you came from. It's the opposite of limiting.
I should also say, as I did in Chapter 1, that "Beerwah" is the name of the mountain, and was never the name of the park's land. The park was a business that borrowed the name from a landmark, which is what many businesses do. I don't object to the borrowing. I'd just like it noticed that the name was borrowed, and that the book never says from whom.
The money and the mission
I think it's important to be fair to the Irwins about what the money was for.
Bob says that "every single cent" went "straight back into the running of the park" (LCH p. 66). He writes that, after Steve's success on television, "the zoo was now essentially focused on a more commercial platform. While their educational message was thriving as a result of that, I was starting to see that the vitally important work was taking place behind the scenes, in securing habitat for animals in the wild" (LCH Ch. 8, p. 169). That's a man who understood the business as a means to an end. The end was land for wildlife. I respect that.
Terri puts it just as plainly. She describes the zoo as "an expanding enterprise, part of an ambitious conservation effort and a complement to our wildlife documentaries" (S&M Ch. 13). And she takes a stand against a rival business model: "Killing crocs for money is not conservation," she writes, about the crocodile farmers who "arrogantly described themselves in public as 'crocodile conservationists.' I found this disgustingly deceptive" (S&M Ch. 10). She also says the farmers "ignored efforts to control or regulate them or provide alternatives, such as ecotourism." Ecotourism, in other words, is Terri's proposed good version of business.
Bob goes further, and I find this part admirable. Of crocodile farming he says: "I have always been vehemently against this industry, because I believe we shouldn't farm and destroy any native wildlife for profit," and, of the phrase "sustainable use": "I don't care whether it's crocodiles, kangaroos or emus, I don't think we have the moral right" (LCH Ch. 4, p. 100). I'm going to come back to that last sentence in Chapter 10. The Irwins turned down a kind of money. That's a real moral position, and a costly one, and I don't want to skim past it.
So here's the argument for the defence, put as strongly as I can. The Irwins started with a shed. They grew through tourism and television. They put the proceeds into habitat and a charity (the closing material of Steve & Me mentions Wildlife Warriors Worldwide, founded in 2002). They declined to profit from killing animals. In most business stories, a person who did what they did would be a hero. I think there's a lot of truth in that.
Where the book goes quiet
But I'm writing as a Kabi man, and I read these passages with a question the books don't answer.
The question isn't "did they make money?" The question is: where was the land, and who was it before it was a ticket office?
The Beerwah Reptile Park was built on a block at Beerwah. It opened in 1973. In Chapter 1 I looked at what the books say about how Bob and Lyn came to the block: they bought it, it was "a bare bush block," a "blank canvas." I don't want to repeat that. What I want to add is this. The books are full of numbers about the business. They list acres, dollars, visitors, seats. They give the budget of the arena. And there's no sentence in either of them that says anything about the people whose Country the whole thing was built on, or what, if anything, the business owed them, or what they thought of it.
I want to be precise. I'm not saying there was no arrangement, or consultation, or acknowledgement. I don't know. The books don't say, and I'm not going to fill the silence with an accusation. I'm saying that if you read the two books to learn how the Irwin business grew, you'd come away believing that it grew out of nothing but family effort, television, and the goodwill of the public. And the one party that always has a stake in any business on a piece of Country, the people who belong to it, doesn't appear.
I'd call that a pattern. I noticed it in Chapter 4, where the Aboriginal references were few and passing, and in Chapter 7, where the places were "untouched." Here, it appears in the economics. When the books describe the money, nobody on the other side of the transaction is Aboriginal. The ticket office is just a ticket office. It doesn't say: this ticket office stands on somebody's grandmother's Country.
Visitors, tourism and what they come to see
There's another side to this I want to mention briefly.
The business of the Irwins was, in part, selling a particular idea of Australia. Terri tells us that when the American network NBC's Dateline wanted to film Steve, she called the Queensland Tourism and Travel Commission in Los Angeles and said that the segment "will showcase Queensland to people in America." The answer on the phone, she says, was: "What you are showing off of Queensland is not how we want tourists to see our fair country" (S&M Ch. 11). Crocodiles and venomous snakes were, in the Commission's view, the wrong advertisement.
That story is funny, and it also shows that the Irwins were building a picture of the country for outsiders, one with big animals, big spaces, and a friendly, dangerous larrikin to guide you. Later, in a chapter of the Last Crocodile Hunter narrated by Judy Irwin, Bob's wife, there are "visitors from all over the world," to whom Steve wanted to show "exactly why crocs rule" (Ch. 11, p. 211).
I'd say that this is where the business and the "untouched" language of Chapter 7 meet. A tourist business that sells wilderness has a reason to prefer that the wilderness have no people in it. If you were selling a trip to a place with an Aboriginal landowner, you'd have to mention them. You'd have to share the story, and perhaps the money. If you're selling the bush, you don't.
That's a speculation about incentives, not a statement about anyone's motives, and I want to keep it that way. I'm not accusing the Irwins of anything. I'm saying that the story told by two books of the business of the bush has a gap in the shape of the people who were there first, and I think the gap isn't an accident of two authors' memories but a habit of a whole industry.
What the best version looks like
I don't want to write only criticism. So let me say what I'd like to see instead. These are suggestions, and I'm not an expert in tourism or commerce, so take them as an ordinary man's wish list.
- An acknowledgement of Country on the gate, the website, and the program. It costs nothing. Many Australian businesses and institutions do it now. I'd want it to name the right people, which means asking.
- Telling the Beerwah story properly. The mountain means something. A zoo that carried the name of a mountain in its first years could tell its visitors that this is a Kabi Kabi, Gubbi Gubbi and Jinibara place (I explained the three names in Chapter 1), and that the stories of the Glass House Mountains belong to them, with their permission and in their words.
- Paying for it. If a business uses the stories or the culture, pay for it, properly. Kabi Kabi and Jinibara people have organisations that can say how.
- Aboriginal people employed in the work and the leadership, not only in the souvenirs.
I know that some of this may already be happening. I haven't been to Australia Zoo recently, and I'm writing about the books, not the park today. If it is happening, good. I'd like to see it in the next edition.
What the forty cents bought
Let me return to forty cents.
I said it was an honest number, and I meant it. But there's something else in it. A gate fee is the price you put on being allowed to come in. Bob built a ticket office and a fence: "an eight-foot-high security fence around the entire three and a half acres" (LCH Ch. 2, p. 38). It was a fence for keeping venomous snakes in and visitors safe, and I'm not suggesting anything sinister in it. But I can't help thinking that the whole Irwin storyis, in one sense, the story of a gate, and of the price of coming through it.
What I'd ask, as a Kabi man, is simply: who held the gate for us?
In the next chapter I'll go from the gate to the land. When the Irwins had money, what did they do with it? Bob and Terri both describe buying land, "buying back the bush," as I'll call it, and I want to ask what it means to buy back country that was never yours to begin with.