If you want to know what a book believes about the land it's describing, don't look at the sentences where it says what it believes. Look at the adjectives. The adjectives are where the writer relaxes. A writer who would never say "this country was empty when we came" will happily say "pristine, untouched part of the world," because the adjective feels like scenery, not like politics.
I want to go through the adjectives in the Irwin books, as I did the Aboriginal references in Chapter 4, by listing them, quoting them, and then asking what they're doing. I'm going to be careful with the evidence, because this is the chapter where it would be easy to overreach. People use the word "pristine" about all sorts of things, including beaches without litter, and I'd be foolish to treat every use as a political statement.
The list
Here's what I found by searching the two books for "pristine," "untouched," "wilderness," and a few of their cousins.
*In The Last Crocodile Hunter:*
- "Hidden Valley, a pristine and isolated part of the world complemented by the impressive Mount Wickham in the distance. It was apparent that anything could remain unfound in a place like this" (Ch. 4, p. 133; this is the herpetologist John Cann, as I read the voice, writing about a place that "Bob and Steve had nicknamed 'Hidden Valley'").
- "We traversed a dramatically changing landscape across untouched areas of national parks as large as some small countries" (Ch. 9, p. 181, in a passage about the Top End research trips).
- "The beauty of this wilderness area suddenly made the hardship of our journey feel insignificant" (Ch. 9, p. 182).
- "In this pristine, untouched part of the world, we just kept pulling out bigger and bigger crocodiles from our traps… It was a good sign that crocodiles were thriving without humans encroaching in their environment" (Ch. 10, p. 188).
- "We wanted it for wildlife, and it was perfect wilderness country, surrounded by national park and state forest" (Ch. 13, p. 235, Bob on the property near Kingaroy that he and his wife Judy bought in 2008).
- And one use that is about a clean beach, not about people: "beaches back in Australia were pristine in comparison, especially in the more remote areas that I frequented" (Ch. 3, p. 90, Bob looking at a sea full of rubbish overseas).
*In Steve & Me:*
- "There are still plenty of places in the vast Australian wilderness where he could get away from it all, places where he could drive for days without seeing another person" (Ch. 14, about why Steve felt grounded in Australia).
- "In the middle of this vast landscape were the two of us, the only people for miles," followed, a few lines later, by a cattle station that was "a small homestead in the middle of nowhere" (Ch. 7, during filming).
- Lakefield, which Terri calls "one of my favorite places in Australia" and which "Steve considered… the most beautiful place on the face of the earth" (Ch. 11), and "our school of the bush" (Ch. 17).
That's not a long list. But I'd say it tells a story, and it's a more consistent one than any of the individual sentences.
What the words say
Let me try to put what these sentences share into plain words.
One. The best places are the ones that have no people in them. Not "no people at the moment." The idea is that people are the thing that damages a place, and that a place is at its best when they're absent. Look at Bob's sentence about Lakefield again: "a good sign that crocodiles were thriving without humans encroaching in their environment." Humans encroach. They arrive from outside, and nature, here, is the thing they come to. And look at Terri's: "places where he could drive for days without seeing another person." The pleasure of the place is that it contains nobody.
Two. These places are far. "Remote." "Far-flung." "The middle of nowhere." I'd like to say something about this word, because it has a very particular meaning. A place is remote from something. It's remote from a city, from a road, from the place where the person who's describing it lives. A place can only be "the middle of nowhere" if you start from somewhere else. For the Aboriginal people of Cape York, Lakefield isn't the middle of nowhere. It's the middle of home, as I'd guess.
Three. To be there is to find something. "Anything could remain unfound in a place like this," says Cann. I dealt with the language of discovery in Chapter 4, but here it is part of the pattern. The discoverer arrives at the untouched place and finds what's in it. He names it. The people to whom it was never lost are not in the sentence.
Four. The wilderness is pure. That's what pristine means. It originally meant "belonging to the earliest time," from the Latin word for "former," and it came to mean unspoiled, as it was at the beginning. Bob's own use of the word about beaches, "pristine in comparison" to a sea of rubbish, is a good example of the plain meaning. There, it's about being clean. I accept that. If Bob had used "pristine" only for clean beaches, I'd have nothing to say. The problem is that in a place full of people's history the same word is also used to mean the way it was before anyone was here. The word slides between the two meanings. Clean of rubbish; clean of people.
Fair is fair: what the words are for
I've been hard on the adjectives, so let me say what they're for, as I understand it.
Bob and Terri use these words as conservationists. They are talking about ecosystems that haven't been fragmented by clearing, drained, mined, covered with houses, or fished out. In science, "wilderness" has a specific meaning in conservation, something like large, intact country with little industrial disturbance, and the Irwins are using it in that spirit. When Bob says he wanted "somewhere that wasn't totally destroyed by land clearing" (LCH, Ch. 13, p. 235), I hear a man who has watched bulldozers take country, and who wants to protect what's left. He wanted it "for wildlife," not for cattle. He bought a place with "no infrastructure," and spent twelve- to fourteen-hour days making it habitable. I think that's honourable. I'd love more people to buy blocks to leave them alone.
And, truthfully, I think the crocodile claim is probably right too. If an area has had less hunting and less development, you'd expect to find bigger crocodiles. The Irwins are speaking as people who've seen the difference between Lakefield and the heavily settled east coast, and Bob says so in the same passage: "as was occurring in the ever-expanding urbanised areas of the fastest growing state in Australia, the east coast of Queensland" (LCH, Ch. 10, p. 188). I would never tell a man that the contrast between a paddock and a river is imaginary.
So I'm not accusing the Irwins of using the words to make a political point. I'm saying the words do political work whether or not the speaker intends it.
What "untouched" can't mean
Here's why I care.
In 1992, the High Court of Australia, in the case known as Mabo (No 2), rejected the idea that this continent had been terra nullius, land belonging to no one, at the time of British arrival, and recognised that native title could exist under Australian law. I discussed it in the Introduction. I won't repeat it, except to say that after 1992 it became legally impossible to say that the land had belonged to nobody. Most Australians, I think, absorbed that as a fact about the law, and carried on using the old word in the old way.
"Untouched" is terra nullius in the form of an adjective. It says: nobody's hand was on this. And that's the thing I think can be shown to be wrong, as a matter of plain evidence, in every place the Irwin books use it:
- Lakefield / Rinyirru. The Queensland Parks page says "Nine different Aboriginal clans, made up of at least 75 key family groups, occupied this area prior to European settlement," and that "the landscape has major Aboriginal cultural significance and features many occupation, ceremonial and story places." That's a touched landscape in the deepest possible way. Some of it has been protected by law for thousands of years.
- The Mary Valley, which is part of my own Country. In April 2023 Jinibara, Kabi Kabi and Butchulla Traditional Owners joined scientists on a ten-day canoe survey of the Mary River, from Kenilworth to Tiaro. The Gympie Today report said the expedition "discovered evidence of occupation along the entire river," including artefacts and scar trees. Later, on ABC News, Kabi Kabi man Kerry Jones said, standing at one site: "This is where they would've sharpened their spears up… Just from the rock material that we've been finding, and the hundreds and hundreds of stone tools. It really opened our eyes up and took us back in time" (ABC News, 26 September 2024). Kabi Kabi man Norman Bond told the ABC: "It may have been over 100 years since our people traversed down the river knowing that it's freehold now" (ABC News, 19 April 2023). That is a river that has been touched for a very long time, and is being read again by its own people.
- Bob's own book. On one of his reptile trips (LCH, Ch. 2, p. 61), in what he calls the red sandy hills of the "escarpment country," he writes: "we discovered areas in the escarpment country where the Indigenous people had lived in ancient times—we found signs of where they'd made their tools and where they'd camped." So Bob noticed it, in his own book. (The book doesn't say which place this is, and I won't guess.)
That last point is the one I find hardest to let go of. Bob, early in the book, notices the tools and the campsites. A hundred and twenty pages later, a passage calls Lakefield "untouched." The two pages never meet. The man who saw the signs didn't connect them to the word he used on the next trip.
The landscape that was made
There's a further, subtler point, and I want to say it carefully, because it's contested ground among historians and I don't want to claim more than I can show.
The standard view among many scholars today, in books like Bill Gammage's The Biggest Estate on Earth (Allen & Unwin, 2011), is that many of the landscapes that early colonists described as natural, open, park-like country were in fact the result of deliberate, careful management by Aboriginal people, particularly through fire. Gammage's argument is that when the first settlers wrote about country that looked like a gentleman's park, it looked that way because it was a kind of park, tended for thousands of years. I'm not saying every landscape in Australia fits that. I'm saying it's a serious claim by a serious historian, and it means that "untouched" may often be the opposite of what happened. The country looks wild because it was tended so well that the tending didn't show.
I can only say that as a reader, not as an authority on fire. It's not Kabi knowledge that I'm claiming, and I wouldn't tell you what my old people did with fire on the Mary or at Beerwah, because I haven't been taught enough to say. What I can say is that the idea that a landscape can be both loved and managed by people, and still be rich in wildlife, is exactly what the word "untouched" cannot hold.
The bush as a place with no one in it
I want to say what I think the adjectives are really about, because it's the same thing that I looked at in Chapter 2, in Bob's boyhood, and at in Chapter 5, in the Crocodile Hunter. It's a picture of the bush. In that picture the bush is a place you go to be alone. It's a place where you prove yourself, and are changed, and come back. It gives you a school and a calling. The picture is, as far as I can tell, a deeply sincere one. It's the picture on which the whole of the Irwin family's adult life was built, and it's a beautiful thing to love.
And it only works if the bush is empty. If there's somebody there, a family, an old woman who knows where the water is and what the stars mean, then the bush is not your school. It's their house, and you are a visitor. Which would be fine. Visitors are welcome. But the whole of the myth depends on the visitor being the first.
I'm not saying the Irwins knew they were doing this. I'm saying the words went in without anyone noticing, as they have for two hundred years, and that they are doing work that nobody asked them to.
A few honest alternatives
I'm not going to tell the Irwins which words to use. But since I've been critical, I think it's fair to offer some, and they're only suggestions.
- Instead of "untouched," you could say "cared for," or "still intact," or "not cleared." Each says something true about ecosystems without saying anything false about people.
- Instead of "pristine and isolated," you could say "rich and hard to reach," which is what you mean, and leaves open who lives there.
- Instead of "remote," you could say "a long way from Beerwah," which is accurate and honest about where you're standing.
- Instead of "wilderness," you could say "country," and then say whose.
None of these costs anything. I'd think they'd even be better writing.
Beerwah, again
I'll finish where I began, at the mountain.
When Bob and Lyn bought their three and a half acres in 1972, the book describes the "bare bush block" this way: "It was a blank canvas, but at least it was our very own blank canvas" (LCH, Ch. 2, p. 37). I picked the same words up in Chapter 1. Blank canvas is the cousin of "untouched." It's the same idea, said by a man arriving. A canvas is blank until somebody puts something on it.
Beerwah wasn't blank. It's a mountain with a name, and the name was given by people who were here long before 1972. Whatever they painted, a canvas was never what they found.
In the next chapter I'll follow the Irwins' picture from the bush to the business. I want to ask what it means that a park built on a place described as empty became a very successful enterprise, and I want to start with a sentence in Steve & Me about a hundred visitors and six hundred and fifty dollars.