Rex reads this chapter. Tap a line to start there.

Chapter 6

"With Your Permission": Cattle Creek, Lakefield and the Question Nobody Asked in Print

I said in the last chapter that there's one scene in the whole story of the Irwins' crocodile work where somebody asks permission. This chapter is about that scene, because I think it's the best thing in either book for showing how the Irwins understood the word, and I'd like to be fair to it before I say what I think is missing.

It's in The Last Crocodile Hunter, in the middle of Chapter 4, and it isn't told by Bob. It's told by a man named Stephen Accornero, whose family farmed sugar cane at Cattle Creek, near Ingham, when Bob and Steve first turned up there in the late 1980s. Bob gives him a few pages of the book, which I think is generous, and which says something nice about how Bob thought of the people who helped him. Here's how Stephen remembers it:

"Dad, Mum and I were having our regular 3 p.m. 'smoko' break on our family sugarcane farm when we noticed a mysterious vehicle approaching the back of our house, loaded up with camping gear, nets, tarpaulins, large wooden crates and an upturned dinghy… 'I'm Bob Irwin and this is my son, Steve. We'd like to catch crocodiles on your property, with your permission,' the older bloke said." (LCH, Ch. 4, pp. 105–106)

I love that scene. I'll tell you why in a moment. First, here's what comes next. The Accornero family doesn't just say yes, they're delighted and a little bemused. Bob promises, "We'll be completely self-sufficient. You won't even know we are there," and Stephen's father says, granting them permission, "Okay, then, you can set up your camp here." And Stephen writes that the years of listening to Bob and Steve "had a deep and profound effect on our family and our way of farming." When the farm went from cattle to cane, they "left wildlife corridors along our creeks," and "a couple of hundred acres to the environment." And: "that wasn't because of a government department regulation; that was all because of the Irwins" (LCH, Ch. 4, p. 106).

That's a wonderful thing for a family to say about two men who came to the door. It means the way the Irwins went about it, polite, respectful, asking, left something behind. I believe it, and I'm glad. A great deal of the harm done on this continent has been done by people who didn't knock.

What the scene shows

Let me say plainly what I think the Accornero scene shows about the Irwins' idea of permission.

First, permission is a thing you ask of an owner. Bob and Steve got a map from Queensland Parks and Wildlife showing "the private properties that accessed" the creek, and "from there on, it was our responsibility to build relationships with the owners so we could access their properties" (LCH, Ch. 4, p. 105). They put on their "best khaki shirts" and "went door-knocking around Ingham." The Irwins looked at the creek, identified who was on the title, and went and asked. That's good manners and I'd say it's also good practice, and it's how a lot of people in rural Australia expect it to be done.

Second, permission goes to people with a document. The map showed the private properties. The state gave Bob and Steve a permit. Those were the two kinds of authority the scene recognises: the Crown's (the permit under the Fauna Conservation Act, which I discussed in Chapter 3) and the landholder's (the Accornero family, who held the land). If you hold one of those, you can grant leave. If you don't, you aren't asked.

Third, and this is the part that interests me most, the permission is for something that nobody else is thought to have a stake in. Look at how Stephen describes the place Bob wanted to camp: "it was an uninhabited area that we used solely for running cattle." Uninhabited. I think he means nobody lives there now, and I'm sure he's right, it was a cattle paddock. But the word is doing what the word has always done on this continent. It's telling us the place is empty, and it's telling us in the language of a farming family who have been there for a long time, and who see it that way because they've been told it that way, and have never been asked to think otherwise.

I don't blame the Accornero family for that. I think it's a perfectly natural thing for a farmer to say about his own paddock. I'm pointing out that the whole of the permission system in this scene, the state, the farm, the map, the title, is a chain that starts at 1788 and doesn't include the people who were on the creek before then.

Whose creek?

I have to be careful here, because I'm not from that Country, and I won't pretend to know the people of Cattle Creek or the Ingham area, who they are, how they speak, and what they'd say. They have their own voice. I only know that there are Aboriginal people whose Country includes that part of the coast, and that nothing in the book says whether anyone asked them.

I want to be clear that I'm not saying the Irwins didn't ask. I'm not claiming that. The book doesn't say either way. What I'm saying is that the book doesn't say, and that in the one scene where a family tells how the Irwins asked permission, the two kinds of authority recognised are the government and the landholder.

Let me put that in the plainest form I can. In the telling, Bob and Steve asked everybody they were required to ask, and some they weren't, such as the local farmers who weren't obliged to give anything. They were polite beyond the call of duty. That's the standard the Irwins held themselves to. And by that standard, I think they'd be the first to say they could have asked the people of the Country, too. I think the omission is a matter of habit, of how the thing was seen, and not of rudeness.

Lakefield

Now to the place where the research trips happened.

The research expeditions, which Bob describes in Chapters 9 and 10 of LCH, were done at Lakefield National Park, in Cape York. Bob describes it as "a training course and a classroom like no other, led by a father and son team in the far-flung location of Queensland's Lakefield National Park" (Ch. 9, p. 176). Another voice in the book calls the trips "the beginning of the real test, the training ground, and the making of the core team" (Ch. 9, p. 176). Later the team is "traversing a dramatically changing landscape across untouched areas of national parks as large as some small countries" (Ch. 9, p. 181); the camp is set "in a very remote part of Australia" (p. 182); and "the beauty of this wilderness area suddenly made the hardship of our journey feel insignificant" (p. 182). The final expedition is described like this:

"In this pristine, untouched part of the world, we just kept pulling out bigger and bigger crocodiles from our traps each and every time. It was a good sign that crocodiles were thriving without humans encroaching in their environment…" (LCH, Ch. 10, p. 188)

*Untouched. Pristine. Without humans encroaching. I'll deal with those words at length in the next chapter, so I'll only say here that they appear in the middle of a description of a place whose name, to the people who belong to it, is Rinyirru.*

Let me tell you what I found out. I looked it up. I'm not from Cape York and I didn't know. The Queensland Parks website says: "Rinyirru (Lakefield) National Park (CYPAL) was formerly Lakefield National Park." The park is about 544,000 hectares. "'Rinyirru' is the name for the culturally-significant area of Jeanette Hill and a bora ground near Blue Lagoon in the north of the park." The dedication of the park "represents the transfer to Aboriginal ownership of the largest and most iconic national park in the Cape York Peninsula region." The Traditional Owners are the Lama Lama and Kuku Thaypan peoples, and six named clans and related families. "Nine different Aboriginal clans, made up of at least 75 key family groups, occupied this area prior to European settlement" (Queensland Parks and Forests, "Nature, culture and history," and "About"). And according to the Lama Lama people's own website, a claim to Lakefield was lodged under Queensland's Aboriginal Land Act in 1992; "the land (544,000 hectares) was transferred to Aboriginal freehold land held by the Rinyirru (Lakefield) Land Trust and dedicated as Rinyirru (Lakefield) NP (CYPAL) in 2011." Australian Geographic reported the handover ceremony in June 2011, "after 20 years of negotiations."

Now think about the dates. The Land Court recommended a handback in 1996, according to that same Australian Geographic report. The Irwin crocodile research trips ran through the 2000s: Steve's last was in 2006, and Bob led a team back in July 2007 (LCH, Ch. 12, p. 229). So throughout the whole time that the Australia Zoo team was camping on the river and setting traps at Lakefield, there was a claim, then a recommendation, then negotiations, over who owned the ground. And in 2011 the title went to the Traditional Owners. The Last Crocodile Hunter came out in 2016, five years after that. And the book still calls it "Lakefield National Park" and "pristine" and "untouched."

I don't know what the Irwins knew. I don't know what arrangements the zoo had with the Parks service or with the people who held the claim. I'm not suggesting they did anything improper. They may have done a great deal that isn't in the book. What I can say is that the book doesn't mention a claim, a handback, a name, a Land Trust, a clan or a person from the Country, in any of the passages I read about the place. I searched both books for "Rinyirru," "Lama Lama," "Kuku" and "Thaypan." Nothing. I searched for "Traditional Owner." Nothing.

What I'd have liked to read

I'll make a modest suggestion. If I'd been Bob's editor, I'd have wanted one paragraph. It wouldn't have to be long. It could go in the first chapter about Lakefield, on page 176:

*Lakefield National Park, which the Traditional Owners know as Rinyirru, is Aboriginal land that has been under claim since 1992. We worked there with the permission of [the Land Trust / the Traditional Owners / the rangers] and we are grateful.*

That's all. I don't know if it's true. I'd be glad to learn it is. But I can't find it, and I'd say that it's the one thing that the Accornero scene teaches us we should have. If the Irwins thought it was right to knock on the door of a cane farmer in Ingham, they'd surely have thought it right to knock on the door of the people whose national park was it.

I also want to point out something about Terri's book, because it surprised me. In Steve & Me, Terri calls Lakefield "our school of the bush," "one of our favorite places in the world" (S&M, Ch. 17), and says Steve "considered it the most beautiful place on the face of the earth" (S&M, Ch. 11). She writes about the campsite and the fruit bats at dusk. And she writes that "it was a battle to protect fragile ecosystems like Lakefield from the wildlife perpetrators, from people who sought to kill anything that could turn a profit" (S&M, Ch. 17). There's a lot of love in that. But once again it's a battle between two parties: the Irwins and the people who wanted to profit. The people who've been protecting the place for thousands of years aren't in the story. They're not among the perpetrators, and they're not among the protectors either.

A word on "school of the bush"

There's a phrase that appears in both books, and I think it's worth pausing on. Bob says: "The bush became my school of life" (LCH, Ch. 1, p. 21). Terri says that Lakefield was "our training ground, … our school of the bush" (S&M, Ch. 17). I don't think it's an accident, or that Terri was copying Bob. I think it's just how people on this side of the family think about going out into the bush.

I find it moving. And I'd like to say that on Rinyirru there's a school already, and it's been running for a very long time. The Parks website quotes the Traditional Owners about Rarda-Ndolphin (Low Lake): "Traditional laws protect the lake and its surroundings from all disturbances. Through these laws and customs, the Traditional Owners have managed the park's extensive wetland system for thousands of years." And "Aboriginal people collected valuable food, medicine and material resources from many of the national park lagoons and waterholes, but not from Rarda-Ndolphin." That is a place, in the same park, that people have for thousands of years chosen not to touch. I'd say that's what "untouched" actually looks like. It isn't the absence of people. It's the presence of law.

I'm not telling that story. It isn't mine, and it belongs to the people who gave it to the Parks website. I'm only noting that the word the Irwins used for Rinyirru, untouched, is a word that the people of the Country might use of one particular lake, for reasons the Irwins' book doesn't describe.

The credit side

I don't want to leave the chapter hard-edged. Here's what's true, and I'd like to say it clearly.

The crocodile research done at Lakefield has real value. Bob writes that "Everything we know about crocodiles today grew from the moment those research trips commenced" (LCH, Ch. 9, p. 176), and that the team "processed for the purpose of scientific data over fifty crocodiles" on one trip, "the largest number of crocodiles processed in the history of Australia Zoo's collaborative crocodile research expeditions" (Ch. 10, p. 188). The word collaborative is Bob's and I want to hold on to it. If the zoo's research was collaborative, I'd like to know who collaborated.

The research went on after Steve died. Bob led the team back in 2007 "to continue the crocodile research project in Steve's name" (Ch. 12, p. 229). I admire that. It's an act of love, a thing that was done out of loyalty to a man and to a purpose, in the face of grief.

And the Irwins' own record, in the Accornero scene, shows that when they were asked to think about the people whose ground they were on, they did. They asked, and they stayed, and they left good things behind. I take that as evidence of what they'd do if the question were put to them. I believe the Irwin family would say yes to a Traditional Owner who knocked.

Why this matters to me

I'm writing this book on my own Country, in the shadow of Beerwah, and I know what it feels like to see a place described in print without your name in it. It's an odd, quiet feeling. It's not anger. It's more like standing in a photograph where everybody else has been labelled.

So when I read about Lakefield, I read it as someone who knows what's under the word "untouched." There's a name. There's a claim, and it was made in 1992, and it took nearly twenty years. There are nine clans. Parts of that country are kept from disturbance because the law says so. There were people there when the Irwins' trucks arrived, and there were people there when the book was printed, and the book's silence is the only thing that isn't in the record.

The next chapter takes up the two words I've promised to deal with: untouched and pristine. They run through both books like fence posts, and I think they're the key to everything else.


Notes

Quotes checked against the sources:

  • LCH Ch. 4, pp. 104–106 (Accornero account; "with your permission"; "an uninhabited area that we used solely for running cattle"; "wildlife corridors"; "a couple of hundred acres"; "all because of the Irwins"; Queensland Parks map of private properties; "best khaki shirts… door-knocking around Ingham"). ✔
  • LCH Ch. 9, p. 176 ("far-flung location of Queensland's Lakefield National Park"; "the beginning of the real test, the training ground"; "Everything we know about crocodiles today grew from…"); p. 181 ("untouched areas of national parks as large as some small countries"); p. 182 ("wilderness area"; "very remote part of Australia"); Ch. 10, p. 188 ("pristine, untouched part of the world… without humans encroaching"; "over fifty crocodiles… collaborative crocodile research expeditions"); Ch. 12, p. 229 (2007 trip). ✔
  • S&M Ch. 11 ("most beautiful place on the face of the earth"); Ch. 17 ("our school of the bush", "fragile ecosystems like Lakefield from the wildlife perpetrators"). ✔ I searched both books for "Rinyirru", "Lama Lama", "Kuku", "Thaypan" and "Traditional Owner": zero hits.
  • Note: the text of LCH p. 188 appears to open a section told by a team member rather than in Bob's own voice (the extraction doesn't show who). I cite it by page only. Please check who is speaking at pp. 176, 181–182 and 188 in your copy and adjust "Bob describes" where needed.

External sources (this session): Queensland Parks and Forests, "About" and "Nature, culture and history" pages for Rinyirru (Lakefield) National Park (CYPAL) (544,000 ha; Traditional Owners; Rarda-Ndolphin; "nine different Aboriginal clans… 75 key family groups"); Lama Lama website, "National Parks – Joint Management" and "History" (1992 claim; 2011 transfer to the Rinyirru (Lakefield) Land Trust); Australian Geographic, "Biggest park in Cape York handed back" (June 2011; Land Court recommended handback 1996 — quoted from the article's text; "20 years of negotiations"). Please check the 1996 date and the "June 2011" ceremony against a second source before print, and verify the clan names if you quote them.

Author-voice lines to approve:

  1. "I'm not from Cape York and I didn't know" and the whole "I looked it up" passage. This is a sensible stance for a Kabi writer, but confirm.
  2. "I believe the Irwin family would say yes to a Traditional Owner who knocked": it's a generous prediction about people I'm not able to know; it's framed as belief, but you may want to cut it.
  3. The imagined paragraph ("Lakefield National Park, which the Traditional Owners know as Rinyirru…") is a suggestion I wrote for you, clearly marked as hypothetical, with square brackets. Keep, cut or reword.
  4. "It's the one thing the Accornero scene teaches us we should have" and "the book's silence is the only thing that isn't in the record": rhetorical flourishes; soften if they overreach.

Judgment calls: (a) I did not claim the Irwins failed to get permission from Traditional Owners or the Land Trust; only that the books don't mention it. (b) I referred to the zoo's "claim" timeline by reading dates together; I did not state that the Irwins knew about it. (c) I didn't tell any Cape York story; I quoted only what the Parks website publishes as Traditional Owner information, and said it's not mine to tell.