Rex reads this chapter. Tap a line to start there.

Chapter 5

Who Is the "Crocodile Hunter"?

The name is a good one. I'll say that first. "The Crocodile Hunter" is four syllables and a picture: a man in khaki shorts, a big animal, a bit of danger, a grin. Whatever I think about the rest of what's in these two books, I understand why the name worked, and I'd like to start by being straight about what it means to the people who wrote it.

Here's what it means to them. It means a man who goes after crocodiles in order to save them. Terri says it outright in Steve & Me, at the end of her account of a crocodile rescue on Cattle Creek:

"He was gifted with the ability to hunt down wildlife. But he hunted animals to save them, not kill them. That's how the Crocodile Hunter was born." (Steve & Me, Ch. 5)

Bob says it, too, in his own way, in the book that carries the same title with the word "last" in front of it. When he and Steve first approached the Accornero family in Ingham for access to Cattle Creek, Bob "told us that they wanted not to hunt crocodiles but to save them" (The Last Crocodile Hunter, Ch. 4, p. 106, in Stephen Accornero's words). The title of Bob's book, in other words, is a bit of a joke on itself: it's about a hunter who isn't one.

I want to take that seriously. I think the Irwins have made a really interesting move with this word, and I think it deserves a chapter. Here it is: they've taken the word hunter, which in the English of this country means a killer and, since the 1940s, a particular kind of killer with a rifle and a hide-buyer, and they've turned it around to mean a man who catches an animal to keep it alive. And then they've drawn a hard line between the old kind of hunter and the new kind. That line is, in my view, a moral line about what hunting is for. I'd like to look at where it runs, because I think it runs right through the middle of the Aboriginal question too, and the books never notice.

The two hunters

Let's start with the bad hunter. He appears in both books, and he's drawn very clearly.

In LCH, he's the man with the .303. Bob writes that "the impact of hunting on crocodile populations had been minimal until the advent of .303 rifles in the 1940s," that with the rifle "there was now a reliable method to gutlessly shoot our apex predators," and that "Cairns became an international hub for this lucrative new trade in hides, which attracted commercial and professional hunters and other recreational enthusiasts from far and wide." By the time the reptile park opened, "saltwater crocodiles had been nearly hunted out of existence" (LCH, Ch. 4, p. 99). Gutlessly. That's a strong word, and I agree with the sentiment.

In S&M, he's a man in a pub. Steve and Terri, driving home from a crocodile farm, stop at a general store with a pub attached, and some of the patrons recognise Steve from television. One of them "bragged": "I'm a crocodile hunter too… Only I'm the real crocodile hunter. The real one, you hear me, mate?" Terri explains that he "made his living at the stuffy trade," which means baby crocodiles mounted by a taxidermist to be sold as souvenirs, and she says the hunters kill them by driving screwdrivers "right through the bloody eye sockets" (S&M, Ch. 10). That's the villain. In that scene the Irwins stand for the animals and the other man stands for the killing; Terri's account has them leaving rather than arguing.

So the books' moral map has two kinds of hunter. The bad one kills for money, for skins, for souvenirs, or for sport. In Bob's final chapter, the target is trophy hunting: "Nothing makes my blood boil quite like the topic of trophy hunting… I find it difficult to understand how anybody could get any pleasure or satisfaction from killing an animal, full stop" (LCH, Ch. 14, p. 254). And the good one catches an animal, measures it, tags it, drives it hundreds of kilometres and lets it go, so that it'll have "a good, healthy fear of humans" (Steve, in S&M, Ch. 5) and "never get caught again."

I think that's a fine moral map, as far as it goes. I think crocodiles are better off for it, and I'm glad the Irwins made it popular.

The third hunter

Now here's where I want to draw attention to something. Look again at that last quotation from Bob. Here's the whole of it:

"I find it difficult to understand how anybody could get any pleasure or satisfaction from killing an animal, full stop. Not because they need to kill that animal to survive themselves, but just because they can." (LCH, Ch. 14, p. 254)

Read that second sentence slowly. Not because they need to kill that animal to survive themselves. So there's a third kind of hunter, one who does need to. Bob doesn't say he's wrong to kill. He sets him apart. He hunts to survive. Elsewhere in the same book, the person who "had long hunted crocodiles for their meat using traditional methods" (LCH, Ch. 4, p. 99) is described without condemnation, and as I said in Chapter 4, with a degree of respect. So Bob, when he is thinking clearly, knows that hunting is not one thing.

The problem is that the books never connect those two sentences to the people they belong to. On the very same page, and a few lines earlier, Bob describes fighting to change the Native Title Act over the hunting of dugongs and sea turtles, and that law is the one that protects hunting by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. I'll come to that in Chapter 10, and I'll try to be fair to him and to the argument. My point in this chapter is only that the books' ethics of hunting already contain a place for Aboriginal hunting. They just don't put it there.

That place has a name in the way the books talk, though it isn't quite the same name. The Irwins talk about "the bush," and "the wild," and "country," and a man who goes out into them. The men and women and children of this continent who have been going out into those places, and coming home with food and with story, for longer than anyone can say, are not part of that. They're in the past tense. The hunter is the Crocodile Hunter. He's one man, and he's a hero, and the picture that goes with him is a white man in khaki.

Whose Country is the hunt on?

It's a point of fact that Steve and Bob did much of the hunting that made the name, and the research that came after it, on someone's Country. I want to name a few of the places and just ask the question.

  • Cattle Creek, near Ingham. This is where the books start the story (LCH, Ch. 4, pp. 104–106; S&M, Ch. 5). It's "a vast tidal system popular with locals for fishing and boating," in Bob's words (LCH, p. 105), and Accornero's account says the camp was to be in "an uninhabited area that we used solely for running cattle" (p. 106). Whose Country is it? It's the Country of Aboriginal people. The books don't say whose.
  • The Burdekin River, where Bob and Steve found the turtle, and where Steve and Terri camped (LCH, Ch. 4, pp. 132–133; S&M, Ch. 4). I've dealt with it in Chapter 4. It's someone's, and the book doesn't tell us whose.
  • Lakefield National Park in Cape York. I'll give Lakefield its own treatment in Chapter 6. It's where the Australia Zoo crocodile research project runs "every single year" from Steve's day to the present (LCH, Ch. 12, p. 229), and where Bob, a year after Steve's death, writes that "Steve was in every part of that country for me" (LCH, Ch. 12, p. 231). I'd like to note the word country in that sentence. Bob doesn't use it the way I do. But I'd like to hear what he'd say if I asked him whose.
  • And, of course, Beerwah, where the animals lived when they weren't being filmed.

The books describe the catching of crocodiles in a lot of loving detail: the nets, the weights hung in trees, the blindfolds, the boats. They describe the permission in one place only, which is at the door of the Accornero family, a farming family on freehold land who said yes. "'We'd like to catch crocodiles on your property, with your permission,' the older bloke said." That's the one permission-seeking scene in the whole of the hunting story, and it's a fine one. It's polite and open and the farmer says yes. I'll give it a whole chapter, because it tells us something about how Bob understands the word "permission," and it's chapter six.

The apprentice and the old people

There's one more place where I think the word "hunter" has something to say. It's in Terri's account of how Steve grew up.

"I can pinpoint the exact period when Steve grew into the man who would become so well known to people around the world as the Crocodile Hunter. It was the time he spent alone, with his first dog, Chilli, in the bush for months at a time, trapping and relocating crocs for the government." (S&M, Ch. 12)

I like that very much, and I'd like to say why. She's saying the man is made by the bush. Months at a time, alone, with a dog. It's the same idea Bob has about his own boyhood, which I spent all of Chapter 2 on: that the bush is a school, and that a man comes out of it with something. And it's true. People are made by country. My own people were made by it long before anyone drove a Ute into it.

But there's a feature of this description that's easy to miss. Look at who he was working for: "trapping and relocating crocs for the government." That's the contract. That's the East Coast Crocodile Management Plan of 1987, which Bob describes in LCH (Ch. 4, p. 104–105): "removing them was what we were contracted to do," he says; "Steve and I felt our participation in the program was a way to make the best of a bad situation." They paid ten dollars for a permit "to remove fauna under the Fauna Conservation Act," one of five issued, and "we had to pay a royalty to the state government for every crocodile we took out of the water" (LCH, p. 105).

I raised the Fauna Conservation Act in Chapter 3, and I want to say again how I read it. Under the Act, the animal belonged to the Crown, and the permit was how the Crown gave you leave to take it. Bob and Steve got that leave. In the way that the books tell the story, nobody else needed to be asked, and nobody else was. I'm not saying that was illegal. I'm saying that this is how it worked, and that this is how the name was made. "The Crocodile Hunter" is a man with a Crown permit who goes out into somebody's Country, takes an animal out of somebody's river, and the books tell us about the permit, the royalty, the nets, the boat and the animal. Not the river's name, and not who knew it first.

"Goodbye to croc catching"

LCH has a chapter called "Goodbye to croc catching." It's where Bob, in July 2007, takes the Australia Zoo croc team up to Lakefield to "continue the crocodile research project in Steve's name." It's an emotional chapter, and I don't want to cut across it with my argument. He describes crying alone in the boat. He writes, "I was starting to realise that tears weren't a sign of weakness at all: they were a sign of overpowering, irreplaceable love. I learnt that from Steve" (LCH, Ch. 12, pp. 229–230).

I believe that. I don't believe a word of it is anything but true, and I think it's one of the best things in the book, and I'd like the Irwin family to know that a man who has also lost people read it and was moved.

What I want to say about it is small. When Bob writes that "Steve was in every part of that country for me," he's talking about grief, about how a place becomes a person. And he's right, and that's how Country works. Every part of it is somebody. A campsite, a boat, a road. That's the thing I'd have my readers understand. The Irwins know, from the inside, what it is for a piece of ground to be full of someone you've lost. They do know. What the books don't do is take one more step and say: and for other people it was full of their people, long before, and still is.

Bob also writes about his own retirement from it: "So that was my last crocodile research trip with the team. A huge chapter in my life closed." And then: "For me, and for Steve, if you're not passing that knowledge on, then what are you doing it for? When you get to mentor someone in a field you are very experienced in, there is no better feeling in the world" (LCH, Ch. 12, p. 231). I agree. I've never thought otherwise. It's the best thing he says on the matter, and I'd like to put it beside the thing I said in Chapter 2: when Bob thinks about handing a skill on, he thinks about father and son, a team, a crew. He doesn't think about the people for whom this has been going on for generations, in which the teaching of country to the young is the oldest thing there is.

What the name hides

I've been tough on the books in this chapter and, I think, fair. Let me try to say what I actually think the name hides, because it isn't a scandal. It's something quieter.

The word "hunter" has a colonial shape in English. It's the explorer, the tracker, the white hunter, the bushman. He goes out. He is brave. He comes back with the animal, or the story. The Irwins have done something decent with that figure: they've made him a protector rather than a killer. But they've kept the figure. They kept the man alone in the bush, the one who "discovers," the one with the nets and the khaki, and the one who is never in somebody else's yard. The bush is the place he goes to be the hunter. The bush is empty for him in the way that a stage is empty for an actor.

I'd argue that every Aboriginal person on this continent could tell you what's wrong with that. We are the people who hunt in the bush. We aren't hunters in the television sense. We're hunters in the sense of being at home. And I'd say that it's not an accident the books take such care to separate the good hunter from the bad one, and none at all to put a third one in the room.

I'm not asking for the Irwins to give back their name. Steve Irwin did extraordinary work for animals that most people were afraid of, and the name stays his. What I'm asking is that the next book that tells his story should say that the Crocodile Hunter was a guest in somebody's Country, and that somebody was there when he arrived.

The next chapter takes up the words "with your permission," and the one place in the books where permission is asked for, and I'll try to follow it to where it ought to have gone.


Notes

Quotes checked against the sources:

  • S&M Ch. 5 ("He was gifted with the ability to hunt down wildlife… That's how the Crocodile Hunter was born"; "She'll be afraid of boats from now on… a good, healthy fear of humans"); S&M Ch. 10 (the "real crocodile hunter" / "stuffy" pub scene, screwdriver quote); S&M Ch. 12 (Chilli, "the exact period when Steve grew into the man…"). ✔ Chapter numbers are from the e-book's chapter breaks.
  • LCH Ch. 4, p. 99 (.303, "gutlessly", Cairns, "nearly hunted out of existence"); pp. 104–106 (1987 plan, permit $10, royalty, Accornero quotation); Ch. 12 "Goodbye to croc catching," pp. 229–231 ("Steve was in every part of that country for me"; "tears… a sign of overpowering, irreplaceable love"; "if you're not passing that knowledge on"); Ch. 14, p. 254 ("Not because they need to kill that animal to survive themselves").
  • The "title of Bob's book is a joke on itself" reading is mine (the title is The Last Crocodile Hunter); I didn't find Bob saying so.

Facts to verify or soften:

  • The claim that Cattle Creek and the Burdekin are "someone's Country" and that "the books don't say whose" is correct as to the books. I haven't named the people because I haven't researched them. Optional: add them if you can confirm (e.g., via the relevant native title determinations).
  • "I'm not saying that was illegal": consistent with Ch. 3's reading of the Fauna Conservation Act.
  • I treat the Cattle Creek rescue as in S&M Ch. 5 (it's where the line "That's how the Crocodile Hunter was born" appears); LCH's account of Cattle Creek is Ch. 4, p. 105 ff.

Author-voice lines to approve:

  1. "We're hunters in the sense of being at home" and the whole "third hunter" argument. Please confirm this is how you would say it, especially "I'd argue that every Aboriginal person on this continent could tell you what's wrong with that." That's a sweeping claim; I recommend softening to "many" or "I'd argue that Aboriginal people could tell you…".
  2. "A man who has also lost people read it and was moved" — a personal statement I put in your mouth.
  3. "My own people were made by [country] long before anyone drove a Ute into it": general statement; fine if it fits your voice.
  4. "A guest in somebody's Country": an opinion/request, which I think is fair as an ask. Confirm.

Judgment calls: (a) I presented the Aboriginal hunter as the "third hunter" using Bob's own words about "need to kill that animal to survive." This is an inference of mine, and it's framed as a reading; I did not claim Bob meant Aboriginal people by that sentence. (b) I linked it forward to Ch. 10 (Native Title Act/dugong) without stating that Bob was wrong.